There’s A Town In Kentucky That You Won’t Ever Be Able To Find On A Map, And For Good Reason

It went like this:

When I was a boy, my pa’ and I went to the Elsewhere General Store to get some rock candy and chicken feed. I stood outside while pa’ talked to Mrs. Ellison the shopkeep. Pa’ loaded the feed into the truck and handed me the candy. Right about then there was this loud scream from the schoolhouse. I don’t know right well what happened ’cause pa” told me to stay in the truck, but after that we never went back to Elsewhere.

When I was a few years older, I went back there with some friends. We were just dumb kids foolin’ around. My friend Jason went inside the schoolhouse and I never saw him again. We spent the rest of the day looking for him and later the police did a search but found nothing. Shortly after that the county disconnected Elsewhere road from HWY 280. It’s been about 60 years and you’re the first person to mention the place in half a century, son.

I did some digging after the story. The Calloway County Public Library has a pretty good archive of town history and folklore. I had read every book on the subject, but I’d never seen mention of Elsewhere.

I ended up at the Waterfield Library up on the Murray State University campus looking through old microfilm when I found reference to Elsewhere in the Louisville Courier-Journal. A single paragraph story covered how the unincorporated town was being abandoned for health and safety reasons. It was dated April 2nd, 1953. There was one detail that stood out.

CLICK BELOW TO NEXT PAGE…

More From Thought Catalog

  • http://randommetaphor.wordpress.com abooklover2012

    Reblogged this on random metaphor and commented:
    Great Story!

  • Jonas

    you should consider writing a novel about this if you have the time. really a great story!!

  • http://emtwytte.com/2015/10/31/the-town-of-elsewhere-a-scary-short-story-for-your-halloween/ The Town of Elsewhere: A Scary Short Story for Your Halloween | Words & Deeds

    […] “There’s A Town In Kentucky That You Won’t Ever Be Able To Find On A Map, And For Good Reason” by Seamus Coffey […]

  • https://thoughtcatalog.com/xstockton/2017/10/the-creepiest-urban-legend-about-kentucky-most-people-havent-heard/ The Creepiest Urban Legend About Kentucky Most People Haven’t Heard | Thought Catalog

    […] You can read the incredibly creepy story of Elsewhere, Kentucky here. […]

  • http://www.mo4ch.com/the-creepiest-urban-legend-about-kentucky-most-people-havent-heard/ The Creepiest Urban Legend About Kentucky Most People Haven’t Heard | Mo4ch News

    […] You can read the incredibly creepy story of Elsewhere, Kentucky here. […]

  • http://www.go4viral.org/2017/10/27/the-creepiest-urban-legend-about-kentucky-most-people-havent-heard/ The Creepiest Urban Legend About Kentucky Most People Haven’t Heard – Go4Viral

    […] You can read the incredibly creepy story of Elsewhere, Kentucky here. […]

  • http://paktimessports.club/2017/10/27/the-creepiest-urban-legend-about-kentucky-most-people-havent-heard/ The Creepiest City Legend About Kentucky Most Folks Haven't Heard | Pak News

    […] You possibly can learn the extremely creepy story of Elsewhere, Kentucky here. […]

  • http://verandi.org/shocking/the-creepiest-urban-legend-about-kentucky-most-people-havent-heard/ The Creepiest Urban Legend About Kentucky Most People Haven’t Heard – Verandi

    […] You can read the incredibly creepy story of Elsewhere, Kentucky here. […]

  • https://www.awsocute.com/the-creepiest-urban-legend-about-kentucky-most-people-havent-heard/ The Creepiest Urban Legend About Kentucky Most People Haven’t Heard - AwSoCute Top Stories On The Web

    […] You can read the incredibly creepy story of Elsewhere, Kentucky here. […]

  • https://moonpixlar.pw/content/the-creepiest-urban-legend-about-kentucky-most-people-havent-heard/ The Creepiest Urban Legend About Kentucky Most People Havent Heard | Content

    […] You can read the incredibly creepy story of Elsewhere, Kentucky here. […]

  • http://1stbreakingnews.com/index.php/2017/10/29/the-creepiest-urban-legend-about-kentucky-most-people-havent-heard/ The Creepiest Urban Legend About Kentucky Most People Havent Heard – 1st Breaking News

    […] You can speak the unbelievably creepy-crawly story of Elsewhere, Kentucky here. […]

  • https://dare-to-explore-a-div-of.omni-innotech.com/elsewhere-kentucky-by-seamus-coffey-scary-paranormal-story/ Elsewhere Kentucky By: Seamus Coffey || Scary Paranormal Story – DARE to EXPLORE, A DIV. of OMNI INNOTECH

    […] Story Credit There’s A Town In Kentucky That You Won’t Ever Be Able To Find On A Map, And For Good&nb… […]

  • https://nofspodcast.com/states-of-horror-creepy-folk-legends-across-the-us-part-2/ States of Horror: Creepy Folk Legends Across the US [Part 2] - Nightmare on Film Street

    […] Elsewhere […]

blog comments powered by Disqus