Thought Catalog

Why The Internet Chose Cats

  • 0

It is widely-known that some people are ‘dog people’ and others are ‘cat people’. In fact, in mainstream romantic comedies, whether or not someone is a ‘dog person’ is often central to the evolving relationship. Countless films exist in which someone’s status as a ‘dog person’ or ‘not a dog person’ acts as the primary or major secondary plot conflict.

In early 2010, specific research was conducted by a University of Texas at Austin that found almost 42 percent of Americans self-identify as ‘dog people’ versus only 12 percent who reported they are ‘cat people’. About 28 percent said ‘both’ and 15 percent said ‘neither’. Which means that according to this dude’s research, more people dislike both types of furry housepets than express a distinct cat preference.

Yet the internet widely prefers cats. Some of the most popular Internet memes are related to cats. The /b/, or ‘random’ section of popular image board 4chan, which is reputed to be a ‘den of festering evil’ by people who wince anxiously and mispronounce ‘4chan’ while chatting in office cubicles, once routinely created an entire ‘holiday’ devoted to posting cat pictures. As most common internet culture memes are derivatives, loosely, of things people did on 4chan three years prior, it is unsurprising that the ‘Caturday’ holiday became, like, ‘a thing’ for people who would self-identify as moderate to heavy internet users.

It similarly became popular to caption images with white block text in order to make them funnier; thanks to the unfortunately-named website ‘memegenerator.net’, images with white text on them from the internet became known as ‘memes’ even though ‘meme’ doesn’t mean ‘picture with white text on it’. Cat memes are generally the most popular type of captioned image; people go to websites such as ‘cute overload’, ‘icanhazcheezburger’, and, more recently, ‘cute boys with cats’ and, perhaps the most exciting of a million cat-related Tumblrs, ‘cashcats.biz,’ simply to view pictures of cute cats all day, with or without text thereupon.

Popular themes for internet cat pictures suggest that the cat is perplexed by his/her environment; the cat is demanding of something in a regal fashion [cats may often be implied to be ‘overlords’ or ruling-class characters from science-fiction movies]; the cat is excited to have succeeded at something while remaining oblivious to the practicality of his/her accomplishment; the cat has instructed someone, presumably the viewer, to explain a set of circumstances to it.

Images of dogs are much, much rarer, and are certainly not as widely celebrated. The few well-known dog memes portray the dog as a ridiculous character, often the victim of the cat; popular themes for widely-circulated dog photographs include mocking the dog for not enjoying a plate of vegetables, mocking the dog for making an unusual expression implied to be fear, confusion or strong distaste, or otherwise general amusement at the expense of the dog’s ‘dignity’.

Image via Chris Person

Given the overwhelming preference for dogs apparent in mainstream entertainment media and in statistical analysis among Americans, the cat’s election as unofficial ‘mascot of the Internet’ is a phenomenon worth noting. Certainly, some of this can be explained by facts such as ‘internet culture pioneers are not representative of the norm’; ‘the internet is a haven for subcultures to express preferences less welcome in mainstream society’; and ‘people who are dog people are probably doing things like throwing a Frisbee outside, painting a fence in suburbia, driving to a relevant chain restaurant or giving birth to children in a hospital setting , not going online creating Tumblrs.’

But the University of Texas at Austin’s research focused expressly on specific personality traits that may be common to one type of pet loyalist versus the other. It aimed to examine, in its own words, the “widely held cultural belief that the pet species—dog or cat—with which a person has the strongest affinity says something about the individual’s personality,” according to the head researcher on the project.

The research found that “Dog people were generally about 15 percent more extraverted, 13 percent more agreeable and 11 percent more conscientious than cat people” and “Cat people were generally about 12 percent more neurotic and 11 percent more open than dog people”.

Imagine one were somehow able to contact an individual, possibly an alien from another planet and/or someone who had never before used the internet, who were capable of being objective about internet culture, and if one sat that individual down in front of a computer and encouraged them to explore internet communities for the first time [assumedly one would assist the individual with navigating the internet with the ease of someone who was familiar with it].

Imagine that alien/individual viewing the cultures whereby people take the time to visit a user’s Formspring page simply to ask an extremely dickish anonymous question; whereby people go to great lengths to create communities that are ‘safe havens’ for their child pornography image exchange; whereby people can devote a large amount of time to typing comments involving hysterical allegations that the American president ascribes to a religion to which he has never professed to ascribe; whereby people bother to leave comments strictly to the effect of ‘you suck’ [among numerous other bleak and strange examples].

In this hypothetical situation, it is highly unlikely that the conclusion at which the objective alien individual would arrive upon their introduction to the cultures of the internet would be: ‘People on the internet are agreeable and conscientious.’ Probably, the alien individual would find themselves fixedly yet aimlessly ‘falling into Wikipedia black holes’ and concluding ‘I feel neurotic, people on the internet must be neurotic.’

In other words, the cultures of the internet lend themselves much more naturally to the traits associated with ‘cat people’. Further, an examination of the tone and identity of ‘cat memes’ online suggests that internet users view cats – and by extension, cat people and therefore themselves — as: quirky, capricious, cute, strange, transfixing, difficult to comprehend from the perspective of behavioral psychology, elegant, sullen, regal, dominant, engaging, selfish, spoiled and expressive, among other traits. These are qualities much more likely to be associated with ‘people on the internet’.

Yet further, an examination of the tone and identity of ‘dog memes’, which can be roughly assessed despite having only a limited sampling to study, suggests that internet viewers view dogs – and by extension, dog people – as submissive, unintelligent, unfortunate, clumsy, laughable, simple, blunt, inelegant and passive. Interestingly, the way internet users and those communities who lead the creation of various memes and subcultures view cats versus dogs might well be a salient and useful ‘metaphor’ for how they view themselves versus mainstream people who do not generally participate in internet culture as they do.

Finally, the general origin of cat culture online is worth taking into account, not mentioning the seo services that initially skyrocketed cats past all other internet-fame-seeking animals. It would be pretty sweet if, in the far-flung future, ‘digital historians’ performed detailed analysis of like data trails or something to determine when the very first cat picture was posted to an internet community in context of frenzied worship [as opposed to simply ‘hello, this is my Angelfire page, this is my pet’ – 1995]. Until this is possible, amateur culturalists have only informed speculation on which to base the conclusion that the militant propagation of adorable ‘cat memes’ originated on 4chan and/or other communities otherwise reputed for preferring images ‘extreme’ enough to counteract their mounting desensitization.

These communities often played host to people who were highly early adopters seeking emotional havens on primitive message boards. Before the internet was as entrenched in modern social behavior as it has now become and rapidly increases in being, early arrivals discovered it was possible to view pictures online that it had never before been possible to view in real life, such as bizarre sexual portrayals or extreme images of death and murder the sort that would be taken in a war zone or at a crime scene and not published by professional media. Early adopters seeking emotional safe haven on the internet probably bonded over unsettling or unusual images until such images became commonplace and more and more extreme or grotesque images were required to provide the same sense of novelty to which individuals early to the internet had become addicted.

When a culture revolves around sharing increasingly grotesque images it is unsurprising that these niche communities rapidly became offensive and negative toward one another. Thus, oddly, the image of an adorable kitten in a minefield of the repulsive likely initially offered the same kind of ‘shock value’ that an extreme pornographic image once did.

It is also very likely that the earliest individuals to post kittens and cats on extreme message boards, being highly intelligent as early adopters of technology tend to be, had a degree of self-awareness about the surprising context, i.e ‘isn’t it funny that we are wanking to drawings of sushi being served inside a naked woman’s eviscerated torso and yet we also enjoy kittens’; ‘we are all aware that the fact we enjoy kittens is evidence of our lingering human vulnerability in the face of the fact we are wanking to pictures of fingers being sliced up into tiny pieces’, and ‘we are probably too socially disabled or traumatized by images we have seen here or the reasons that we were attracted those images to talk about things like feelings but we will participate in cute animal exchange as a shorthand for expressing ourselves’ [recall the research determined that cat people are ‘more open’].

This is the most likely theory for how pictures of cats eventually evolved into calling cards on early-adopter message boards, avatars of a private language that soon simply meant ‘we’re human beings who use the internet’, so that when the userbase of individuals using the internet as a major social and cultural platform began to grow, the act of enjoying cat pictures was simply part of the process and not representative of a heritage on niche image boards.

Anyway, it would be pretty sweet if people didn’t go around in real life saying ‘kitteh’ though. When people say ‘kitteh’ or ‘teh kitteh’ IRL … I just… yeah. TC mark

You should follow Thought Catalog on Twitter here.

Read This

More from Thought Catalog

Thought Catalog Videos


    • http://twitter.com/ariez Ariz Guzman

      I heard this on NPR. http://www.npr.org/blogs/money

      The internet chose the cat because it's an animal most people thought everyone else would find the cutest. It's like the stock market. O___o

      ——-
      Ranking Cute Animals: A Stock Market Experiment
      On the surface, Planet Money's first-ever economics experiment was all about cute animals. (You can see the experiment here.) But we were really trying to get a better sense of how the stock market works.

      We got the idea from John Maynard Keynes. Back in 1936, he described the stock market as a particular kind of beauty contest. You see a bunch of women's faces, but you're not supposed to say who you think is prettiest. You're supposed to guess who everyone else will think is the prettiest.

      In the market, Keynes argued, it doesn't make sense to invest in the company you think is best. It makes sense to invest in the company that you think other people will think is best. Because if everyone else invests in a company, the price of its stock will rise.

      Of course, when everyone does this, it leads to a slippery investment world. “We have reached the third degree where we devote our intelligences to anticipating what average opinion expects the average opinion to be,” Keynes wrote.

      Pietra Rivoli, a professor at Georgetown's business school, explains the problem with a market like this: “The key danger is that nobody's really thinking.”

      With her guidance, we tested Keynes's idea. Instead of photos of people, we used videos of cute animals. About 12,000 people participated. When they came to our experiment page, they saw three videos that showed a kitten, a slow loris and a baby polar bear.

      Half the people in the experiment were asked to pick the animal they genuinely thought was the cutest. And half were asked to pick the animal they thought everyone else would find the cutest.
      …………….>Kitten: 75.67% (4,517 votes)
      Slow Loris: 14.73% (879 votes)
      Baby Polar Bear: 9.6% (573 votes)

    • http://kilakilakila.blogspot.com brittany wallace

      neurotic and open…

    • Anon

      tldr

      moar longcat plz

    • http://twitter.com/blingless Dave P

      Where would cats be without the internet? Conversely, where would the internet be without cats?

    • miscellany

      I think cats are just funnier looking. Dogs aren't quite as alien…

    • mikegioia

      What a wonderfully well-written article. I'm on the fence between thinking that it was only the 'cute' factor vs. a subliminal correlation in personality between the hardcore internet users and cats.

      You sold me on the latter.

    • # SisterWolf

      Brilliant. Bravo!

      p.s. I fucking hate cats and I mean hate.

    • thad

      ahahahah cats look so funny

    • Jaimi

      HA! This is amazing! I love your articles, Leigh.
      p.s. I generally dislike cats & prefer dogs & lizards.

    • Eric

      Too much analyzing, not enough fact:

      1) Cats landed 4000 thousand years ago from an alien planet
      2) Cats established the Egyptian empire and built the pyramids
      3) Macedonians/Romans (with the help of dogs) defeated the Alien Cats/Egyptians, casting them into the shadows for years.
      3) Cats have secretly been building back up and have shaped the tech industry into what it is today, for a very specific purpose:
      a. lure us into all becoming internet addicts
      b. saturate us with cute cat photos, thereby weakening dogs protective influence.
      c. implant the internet into our brains, and voila =

      CATS CONTROL OUR MINDS!!!

      I mean seriously, you call yourselves animal lovers yet haven't even seen one of the most terrifying reality-check documentaries of our day, “Cats & Dogs”

    • http://devolute.net devolute

      Important work. I'm glad someone is stepping back and asking 'why?'.

    • Tamber

      Got linked to this- easily the best thing I've read all week. And yes, yes I am a cat person. Yes I've been on the internet a looong time.

    • Number=Address

      This is really quite nice and I agree with your conclusion. One quibble, though; “meme” on the internet does not mean “image with white text,” it means, as elsewhere, “meme.” What does mean “image with white text” is “macro” or “image macro.” That many internet memes are macros is incidental. There are more than enough that are not (happy leo, sad keanu) to make the point clear.

      • Denied0

        Also the term meme came from Richard Dawkins' The Selfish Gene in 1976 to describe the spread of popular culture in terms of genetics.

    • Jack463wine

      It’s true; that’s too many cats in the Internet. It annoys me, because I’m not a cat or even dog person; I’m bird person.

    • http://www.facebook.com/profile.php?id=847814826 Misty Miller Sciarabba

      I believe you left out one of the most likely reasons cats are the unofficial mascotts of the internet:  they are just more photogenic.  Cats have more muscles in their head and face and are able to make more expressions.  Their eyes are bigger compared to their head which gives the AWW factor.   They also have the ability to rotate their forelegs.  This is HUGE.  It means they can swat at, scoop up, or grab things.   They are able to learn from observation more than other animals commonly kept as pets which means they are more likely to mimic human behaviors like trying to open a door by turning a doorknob. 

    • Delphine Devallez

      The Internet is recycling old stereotypes about cats and dogs…

    • http://1internetentrepreneur.com/uncategorized/how-jared-polis-won-the-internet/ 1internetentrepreneur.com » Blog Archive » How Jared Polis Won the Internet

      […] cat photos are the first love of the Internet, cute dog photos aren’t far behind. When Polis posted a picture of his terrier mix Gia to […]

    • http://www.happy-more.com/the-1-purr-cent-internet-fat-cats.html The 1 Purr-cent: Internet fat cats - More happy things! | More happy things!

      […] also a hipster. I write articles about how I hate calling creative people hipsters. This probably isn’t helping. Oh, […]

    • http://www.nobodies.tv/wordpress/?p=104 Katz… | Nobodies

      […] So I decided to investigate. I was assured by colleagues that, in fact, the whole cat craze was not just an Erin quirk, it was an internet phenomenon… […]

    • http://meinkat.com/2013/04/01/six-billion-and-counting/ Six billion and counting | Mein Kat

      […] and one of the more interesting results comes from writer Leigh Alexander, in the blog Thought Catalog. Leigh […]

    • http://relatedstories.wordpress.com/2013/05/04/burning-question-why-is-the-internet-obsessed-with-cats/ Burning question: Why is the internet obsessed with cats? | Related Stories

      […] the internet loves cats via Social Times Why the internet chose cats via Thought Catalog The million dollar question: Why does the web love cats? via Mashable Why do […]

    • http://www.inquisitr.com/846263/infographic-war-for-pet-charity-its-claws-vs-paws/ Infographic War for Pet Charity: It’s Claws vs. Paws

      […] are more a dog person than a cat person, no one can dispute that online and on social networks, cat people usually win. A quick review of some of the biggest sites shows just how much disparity there is.Reddit: Vote […]

    • http://enetview.com/infographic-war-for-pet-charity-its-claws-vs-paws/ Infographic War for Pet Charity: It’s Claws vs. Paws - eNet View

      […] are more a dog person than a cat person, no one can dispute that online and on social networks, cat people usually win. A quick review of some of the biggest sites shows just how much disparity there is.Reddit: Vote […]

    • http://techcrunch.com/2013/07/17/reddit-insight-interview-hack-reactor/ Reddit Insight Is An Awesome Hack That Reveals How The Internet’s ‘Front Page’ Really Works | TechCrunch

      […] to browse through casually (did you know that despite the Internet’s reputation for being obsessed with felines, photos of dogs are actually more prevalent than cat photos on Reddit?) but it’s also a very […]

    • http://servaasschrama.com/2013/07/17/reddit-insight-is-an-awesome-hack-that-reveals-how-the-internets-front-page-really-works/ Reddit Insight Is An Awesome Hack That Reveals How The Internet’s ‘Front Page’ Really Works | Lord of the Net

      […] to browse through casually (did you know that despite the Internet’s reputation for being obsessed with felines, photos of dogs are actually more prevalent than cat photos on Reddit?) but it’s also a very […]

    blog comments powered by Disqus