The latest episode of The Summer I Turned Pretty changes the formula up a bit, placing narration responsibilities in Jeremiah’s care instead of Belly’s. As a result, viewers are treated to the character’s internal turmoil, cognitive dissonance, pings of jealousy, love pains, and more. Viewers have taken to Twitter to respond to the show’s latest course of events. 

Spoiler Warning for Season 2, Episode 5 of The Summer I Turned Pretty

Is all hope lost for Jeremiah? 

Jeremiah: “maybe for the rest of the story it could be me" #TheSummerITurnedPretty
pic.twitter.com/t8jpg60aQE

— bea ◟̽◞̽ FINAL SHOW (@Beatricetpwk) July 28, 2023

jeremiah saying: " maybe for the rest of the story it could be me"

my honest reaction: #TheSummerITurnedPretty pic.twitter.com/QY7jCgAxMe

— guada || TSITP S2 SPOILERS (@fallininthemoon) July 28, 2023

How dare Conrad put our Jere Bear in such a position!

THIS IS THE MOST INSANE THING CONRAD FISHER HAS EVER SAID ON THE SHOW #thesummeriturnedpretty pic.twitter.com/48gC12o9zU

— bree ❀ (@xlangfields) July 28, 2023

Jeremiah already lost one woman who understood him like no other; he can’t lose Belly too

this scene 😔 #TheSummerITurnedPretty pic.twitter.com/0hK5jS88Ug

— rosi✨ (@rosi_mxv) July 28, 2023

#TheSummerITurnedPretty SPOILERS EP 5
–
–
–
–
–
–
–
–
–
–
–
–
–
–
–
–
–
–
–
“my dad always loved conrad better, but i had my mom. she was the only person who ever really saw me.“
</3 pic.twitter.com/28LmzewMIY

— federica was at the final show 🏡 (@sigvoftimes) July 28, 2023

Some viewers will always root for Conrad and Belly 

BIGGEST SMILE ON MY FACE#thesummeriturnedpretty pic.twitter.com/voDXchrsbv

— bree ❀ (@xlangfields) July 28, 2023

Jeremiah had to watch the one he loves fall for HIS BROTHER …not fair 

conrads little “oh shit” and that hand motion when jere walked yeah icb hes hilarious 😭 #TheSummerITurnedPretty pic.twitter.com/tyoYEN7jid

— . (@clairokins) July 28, 2023

Does Jeremiah have Ken-ergy?

jeremiah’s voiceover in ep 5: #thesummeriturnedpretty pic.twitter.com/gQlmww9ovv

— gre; saw harry🌻 (@livindaydream_) July 28, 2023

This is what happy, peaceful love looks like

THE SMILES. THE HANDS. THEY ARE IN LOVE AND IM IN LOVE WITH THEM #TheSummerITurnedPretty pic.twitter.com/7XMON7sTcl

— i (@jellysmine) July 28, 2023

What’s most sad is that he knows

jeremiah only speaks the truth about bellyconrad pic.twitter.com/l0zJIV7m7k

— em (@lolatnug) July 28, 2023

Not everyone wanted Jere to narrate  

me seeing that jeremiah was the one who narrated the episode#TheSummerITurnedPretty
pic.twitter.com/7V7TYbOo0M

— Lin (@fallinmyroses) July 28, 2023

Jeremiah/Belly fans better hope these two can climb quite the hill

how do bellyjeres come back from this im serious #TheSummerITurnedPretty pic.twitter.com/FJ8G8S6vpq

— dylan (@sp1derg1rl) July 28, 2023