Thought Catalog

Dear White Gays: Don’t Listen To Time Magazine

  • 0

Time Magazine recently published an opinion piece (either online or in the magazine, who can tell these days?) by Sierra Mannie, a senior at the University of Mississippi. The title read, “Dear White Gays: Stop Stealing Black Female Culture.” Clearly published to cause a reaction (which obviously it has from me), the piece goes on to describe how gay white men, because of inherent privilege in our society, should stop talking, acting, pretending, or remotely aligning ourselves with black women. This is assuming that every gay white man that talks, acts, pretends to be or aligns himself with just one black woman, because all black women are exactly the same, right?

That was snark, I apologize. Allow me to explain.

Mannie goes on to talk about the very true hardships and disparities black Americans face in this country (I’ve written about it before for Thought Catalog). She’s right, it is very hard to be a person of color in this country, and as a white man — a very gay white man — I have absolutely no true understanding of what that must be like. But what I do have is a very real understanding of generalizations, as all minorities do.

Mannie writes about white males appreciation of Beyoncé (because only black women can like her), or a use of a certain vernacular that apparently belongs exclusively to black women (what about black gay men, can they use it?). She writes that black people don’t have access to everything white people do, and she’s right. That they often must worry about their physical safety, and she’s right. That there aren’t enough venues for black voices to be heard, she’s still right.

I mean, gay white men are everywhere, and everyone loves them. They’ve never, ever been murdered for being gay, or denied housing, or medical care. They’ve never been arrested for being gay, or have had to have the Supreme Court rule that their sex was finally legal, definitely not in 2003. Nope, none of these things are true for gay white men, because they do rule the world (oops, did I just go all Beyoncé on her, my bad, I’ll stick with Madonna, or will I piss off Italians?! FUCK!).

That was more snark, I can’t help myself.

Seriously though, this isn’t a game of, “My minority is worse off than yours,” or, “more of my people have been killed than yours,” because that’s not the point. The point is that recognizing the things that she thinks belongs only to black women is the very thing that causes the separation and hate in our society. There’s a reason why this country is called a “melting pot,” because eventually, once you lose the bullshit separation and start appreciating what makes us all amazing, you start realizing that, “Wow, we’re not all that different after all.”

A while back, Time did a cover story on transgendered people and the greater acceptance they’re receiving. This, that kind of change, is what we should be talking about. What does it mean to be a woman in 2014? What does it mean to be a man? What does it mean to be gay, or straight? Must I, as a gay white man, only like and act in a certain way because I’m a gay white man? Must a person born into the wrong body live with that incorrect sex? Must that black woman pretend to like Beyonce when maybe, just maybe, she likes Katy Perry?

It’s all bullshit. You can be whomever you want to be, and you shouldn’t be belittled, black or white, gay or straight, for who you are, gesticulations and all.

It’s opinion pieces like Mannie’s that get published in reputable outlets only for the sake of a reaction, not an actual conversation. Yes, this piece is also reactionary, but in a very different sense. Just imagine if more people wrote of what made us similar, what brings us together, the internet would be a much happier place.

Mannie ended her piece with, “Check your privilege. Try to strengthen the people around you.” Instead, I’ll end with….

Check your privilege. Try to recognize the good in everybody around you. TC mark

featured image – Time Magazine

More from Thought Catalog

Thought Catalog Videos


    • http://www.clutchmagonline.com/2014/07/times-writer-tells-white-gay-men-stop-stealing-black-female-culture/ Times Writer Tells White Gay Men To Stop Stealing Black Female Culture | Clutch Magazine

      […] Time Magazine recently posted an opinion piece by Sierra Mannie, a senior at the University of Mississippi, titled “Dear White Gays: Stop Stealing Black Female Culture.”  […]

    • https://thoughtcatalog.com/madison-moore/2014/07/white-gay-men-steal-black-female-culture-because-they-are-boring/ TIME’s Right: White Gay Men Steal Black Female Culture Because They Are Boring | Thought Catalog

      […] article has already caused some debate online and on Facebook, primarily by white gay men feeling butt hurt that they got completely […]

    • http://community.sparknotes.com/index.php/2014/07/10/is-your-privilege-better-than-mine/ SparkLife » Is Your Privilege Better Than Mine?

      […] piece published in Time magazine. The response has been passionate (full disclosure: this author took part in that heated discussion, and got a little snarky). Fireballs aside, this gives us a great opportunity to look at privileged […]

    • http://prideequalitypost.woodstitch.com/dear-gays-unite/ Dear Gays: UNITE | Pride & Equality Post

      […] OkCupid, or even boldly espoused in your friendly neighborhood gay bar. In response to her piece, H. Alan Scott chides Mannie and her views largely because of her generalizations, but pieces similar to hers also […]

    • http://essentialpost.com/lgbt/dear-gays-unite/ Dear Gays: UNITE | Essential Post

      […] OkCupid, or even boldly espoused in your friendly neighborhood gay bar. In response to her piece, H. Alan Scott chides Mannie and her views largely because of her generalizations, but pieces similar to hers also […]

    • http://kmoffitt.com/dear-gays-unite/ Dear Gays: UNITE | Kmoffitt

      […] OkCupid, or even boldly espoused in your friendly neighborhood gay bar. In response to her piece, H. Alan Scott chides Mannie and her views largely because of her generalizations, but pieces similar to hers also […]

    • http://triplexnews.com/dear-gays-unite/ Dear Gays: UNITE | Triple X News

      […] OkCupid, or even boldly espoused in your friendly neighborhood gay bar. In response to her piece, H. Alan Scott chides Mannie and her views largely because of her generalizations, but pieces similar to hers also […]

    • http://www.causehub.com/blog/2014/07/11/dear-gays-unite/ Dear Gays: UNITE | CauseHub

      […] OkCupid, or even boldly espoused in your friendly neighborhood gay bar. In response to her piece, H. Alan Scott chides Mannie and her views largely because of her generalizations, but pieces similar to hers also […]

    • http://www.safeschoolsdc.org/content/mississippi-senior-inspires-debate-with-time-open-letter-dear-white-gays-stop-stealing-black-female-culture Mississippi Senior Inspires Debate with TIME Open Letter: 'Dear White Gays: Stop Stealing Black Female Culture' | Safe Schools | Desert Cities

      […] to the piece have varied from emphatic agreement to flat-out dismissal. In a piece for Thought Catalog comedian H. Alan Scott, challenged Mannie to broaden her ideas of what constitutes the “proper” […]

    • http://www.safeschoolsdc.org/content/dear-gays-unite Dear Gays: UNITE | Safe Schools | Desert Cities

      […] OkCupid, or even boldly espoused in your friendly neighborhood gay bar. In response to her piece, H. Alan Scott chides Mannie and her views largely because of her generalizations, but pieces similar to hers also […]

    • http://www.safeschoolsdc.org/content/sierra-mannie-dear-white-gay-men-author-defends-article-on-cnn-video Sierra Mannie, 'Dear White Gay Men' Author Defends Article On CNN - VIDEO | Safe Schools | Desert Cities

      […] who penned an oppositional response to Mannie in Thought Catalog, took the Mississippi student to task on those points in her piece he felt were reductive and […]

    • https://thoughtcatalog.com/erin-cossetta/2014/04/quotes-that-perfectly-explain-racism-to-people-who-dont-see-color/ 23 Quotes That Perfectly Explain Racism (To People Who Don’t “See Color”) | Thought Catalog

      […] Desmond Tutu Read this: 18 Things White People Seem To Not Understand (Because, White Privilege) Read this: Dear White Gays: Don’t Listen To Time Magazine Read this: Explaining White Privilege To A Broke White Person… Read this: How To Be Black Read […]

    • http://queerdiscourse.wordpress.com/2014/07/16/dear-everyone-lets-stop-playing-the-oppression-olympics-and-lets-stand-in-solidarity-to-bs/ Dear Everyone: Let’s Stop Playing the Oppression Olympics and Let’s Stand in Solidarity to BS | Professionally Queer

      […] people reacted to her article. Why yes, those are all separate links, thanks for […]

    • http://wms50summer.wordpress.com/2014/07/17/privilege-and-appropriation/ Privilege and Appropriation | WMS 50 Intro to Gender Studies

      […] Mannie for creating finite parameters as to who can indulge in a certain culture. One response I enjoyed was that of a white gay man who criticized Mannie for writing a piece that sparked […]

    • http://backhandedblues.wordpress.com/2014/07/17/black-women-and-white-gay-men-stop-it-or-i-will-make-you-hold-hands-until-you-get-along/ Black women and white gay men: STOP IT, or I will make you hold hands until you get along. | backhandedblues

      […] which has been lambasted (by white gay men) as extremely homophobic, I’ve seen countless responses and as many counter-responses.  All of them carry that combative tone. All of them carry on what […]

    • http://lavishrebellion.com/2014/07/17/dear-white-gays-and-black-women-you-are-not-each-others-enemies/ Dear White Gays and Black Women, You Are Not Each Other’s Enemies | Lavish Rebellion

      […] gay men and their love for black popular culture and black women, or at least their thoughts. From Thought Catalog to VICE, they noted that maybe they were some underlining rooted issues in Mannie’s piece, […]

    • http://buzzcarl.com/what-white-gay-men-need-to-learn-about-black-women-and-cultural-appropriation/ What white gay men need to learn about black women and cultural appropriation | buzzcarl

      […] magazine op-ed about how black women are being mocked and appropriated by gay white men, some are a little hurt after having their wigs snatched by a woman who’s clearly fed up. Despite all the […]

    • http://isobeldebrujah.wordpress.com/2014/07/21/on-race-and-the-gay-community-part-i/ On Race And The Gay Community Part I | What a Witch

      […] predictably, the series of tubes exploded and a number of other opinions were expressed. Some of them were more rational than […]

    • http://buzzcarl.com/is-black-twitter-dead/ Is 'Black Twitter' dead? | buzzcarl

      […] it was stillborn. It never had a chance. After all, there are very few things that rile white people up more than being excluded from minority […]

    • http://libertyherald.us/ole-miss-student-tells-gay-white-men-to-stop-acting-like-straight-black-women/ Ole Miss student tells gay white men to stop acting like straight black women | The Liberty Herald

      […] Alan Scott from Thought Catalog claims that “opinion pieces like Mannie’s…get published in reputable outlets only […]

    • http://www.theglobaldispatch.com/mississippi-student-sierra-mannie-defends-attack-on-white-gay-men-who-steal-black-culture-87611/ Mississippi student, Sierra Mannie, defends attack on ‘White Gay Men’ who steal ‘black culture’ - The Global Dispatch

      […] that happened to me, personal experiences that have happened to me.” Writer H. Alan Scott penned a response, acknowledging the struggles of black women, but also pointing out white gay men do know what […]

    • http://prideequalitypost.woodstitch.com/gay-guys-can-do-better-than-the-word-basic-too/ Gay Guys Can Do Better Than the Word 'Basic' Too | Pride & Equality Post

      […] uproar of gay men appropriating black female culture is a great example of this (full disclosure: I laid into that debate, resulting in CNN’s Don Lemon saying, “… H. Alan Scott, you can act all gay and […]

    • http://www.causehub.com/blog/2014/10/23/gay-guys-can-do-better-than-the-word-basic-too/ Gay Guys Can Do Better Than the Word 'Basic' Too | CauseHub

      […] uproar of gay men appropriating black female culture is a great example of this (full disclosure: I laid into that debate, resulting in CNN’s Don Lemon saying, “… H. Alan Scott, you can act all gay and […]

    • http://emptyclosets.com/forum/chit-chat/174900-white-gay-men-unfairly-appropriating-straight-black-female-culture.html#post2587788 White gay men are unfairly appropriating straight black female culture? - Empty Closets - A safe online community for gay, lesbian, bisexual, transgender people coming out

      […] not stealing another's culture. When using AAVE, you are not stealing African American culture. Dear White Gays: Don’t Listen To Time Magazine | Thought Catalog __________________ It's been a long day, without you my friend. And I'll tell you all about it […]

    • http://racistnotracist.com/2015/05/dear-gays-unite/ Dear Gays: UNITE - Racist Not Racist

      […] OkCupid, or even boldly espoused in your friendly neighborhood gay bar. In response to her piece, H. Alan Scott chides Mannie and her views largely because of her generalizations, but pieces similar to hers also […]

    blog comments powered by Disqus