17 People Share Their Most Brutally Cringeworthy Hook-Up Story

9. Ashley

I was freshly-single and (way too) ready to mingle, so I thought I would preemptively cockblock myself by wearing one of my roommate’s shirts. (My shirts, and bras, seemed to disappear at the slightest hint of a hookup, which was a problem because once your top is off, your pants soon follow.) She was a proud member of the Itty Bitty Tittie Committee, and I was proudly not. This shirt took 3 sets of hands to squeeze me into — there was no way it was gonna be coming off easily. Later that night, I found myself in the bedroom of this guy named Rusty. Never has anyone looked more like a guy named Rusty than Rusty. The 3 sets of hands that had helped me earlier where in various other bedrooms in the house making mistakes we would laugh about the next morning.

I make some asinine, albeit true, comment about how one of those girls (my roommate) was a virgin. “Haha, she doesn’t know what she’s missing out on!” I said. Totally, embarrassingly leading him on. (100% not my intention.) So he thought I was about the peen, which I am, of course, just not that night.

We started making out. Then he tried to take my shirt off. Poor guy didn’t have a chance. But oh, did he try. He tried real hard to get that shirt off. At one point he was squatting on the bed behind me using both hands. I was giggling like a damn fool because my evil plan had worked. He gave up on my shirt and grabbed a rubber.

“Hahh, um, nooo. I’m good. I think I hear my friend!” I panicked.

“Wtf!” He accused.

“I’m in my period, dude, sorry.” Another asinine, and totally false, statement.

“I don’t believe you.” I’m sure he could already feel his balls going blue.

I asked him if he wanted to see my tampon string.

He declined.

I ended up sleeping the too-tight shirt, alone, in my own bed, that night.

Preemptive cockblocking FTW.

Sorry, Rusty.

10. Shae

This guy I went to high school with and always had a thing for (we both always had our own gf/bf) came up to visit me during my birthday weekend my freshman year in college. 3 day weekend. 1st night we successfully made out at a frat but I was extremely drunk & proceeded to puke (very neatly btw) into a solo cup. Night 2: we went to a house party and he was in the basement grinding with a rando all night. Night 3 rolls around and I finally get this idiot into my room. He keeps having to go to the bathroom and eventually just ends up puking in my trash on my dorm floor. I woke up the next morning and he had slept in my roommates bed. Cool!!



Chelsea Fagan

Chelsea Fagan founded the blog The Financial Diet. She is on Twitter.

More From Thought Catalog

  • http://forevertwentysomethings.com/2016/05/20/girl-bye/ 10 People You Will Never See Again After Graduating College - Forever Twenty Somethings

    […] …and things were never the same afterward. Whether it was sloppy or super, the ship has sailed on how you once thought of each other. Maybe it’ll make for a good awkward hookup story? […]

blog comments powered by Disqus