This Is What We Could’ve Been

 Josh Willink
Josh Willink

I liked you. A lot.

It didn’t start out like that. In fact in the beginning I was only looking for a friend. I, like you was in a new place where our carefully chosen friends whom we deemed “our people” in that crucial first week, would in fact, remain our squad until the end. I wasn’t expecting to find you, but I did.

We became fast friends. Joking, talking, playing and dreaming together. You displayed a rare intelligence and I was actually able to hold a real conversation with you. No inane chatter about insignificant little tidbits. You would call me on my BS and I’d call you out on yours. I didn’t have to pretend with you. Even as a friend I was just being me. My snarky comments, my insights and the things I told you. They were all me. No pretense, just truth. My truth. And somewhere through the shared secret glances, sudoku, inside jokes, workouts and motivational speeches I fell for you. I fell for you hard.

I remember the exact moment I knew I was in trouble. It was when I had told you I was bored in one of our classes, and you went and made me a word-search. A gosh darn word-search from scratch. That was my turning point. I knew if nothing else, I wanted to stay your friend. If I could get more, then great but I would be willing to settle with us just being friends. That’s how much I admired you.

You had a girlfriend. She was closer to you in age, knew your secrets and she was gorgeous. I wouldn’t play with fire, and so I kept my crush to myself hoping it would go away. But it didn’t, it stayed inside me like a particularly stubborn ember that refused to be extinguished. Then the unthinkable happened, you two broke up. I knew it would be to soon to try anything with you, but I could start flirting with a clear conscious, you were a free agent.

So that’s what I did. I flirted, I opened myself up to you and let you inside my head. I slept over and we spent the nights just talking and with each word I fell harder under your spell. We had tickle wars which you won solely on the fact that you were bigger than me. We gave each other massages (sorry I was so bad at that). We had honest conversations.

That was my mistake. I’ve always been a sucker for beautiful words and yours enveloped me into a perceived bubble of safety. Perhaps I read more into our time together than you did. Though there were a few times I did honestly thing there was a chance you liked me too. Apparently I was wrong, oh so wrong. You didn’t even like me enough to stay friends.

I was going to tell you the last time I slept over, but like a coward I chickened out. I was too afraid of what your response would be, that I didn’t want to risk making things awkward and losing you. So I kept my mouth shut and continued to smile along. The minute I left your place I knew I had made a mistake. I spent the next week and a half gathering up as much courage as I could and I sent you a text. I asked you to meet me. Sink or swim I was ready. I was ready for all possibilities. Rejection or reciprocation. At this point I just needed to tell you. We both know what happened.

I waited for your text to let me know when you wanted to reschedule. And when I didn’t hear from you for a week I knew I had lost you. You had already been long gone.

It hurt. It hurt more than I’d like to admit, because you didn’t ghost on a girl who liked you, you ghosted on a friend. What did I do or say? When was it you knew you wouldn’t be reaching out again? Was there a specific moment? Or did it just gradually creep up on you? I guess my question would be: why?

Always the type to find the silver lining, you taught me a valuable lesson. I shouldn’t be afraid to speak my truth. No matter the outcome I should be honest and take the risk. For it is far better to take the plunge and live without the “what-if?”. what if I had told you that last weekend? Would it have ended differently? Or were you already half gone? I shouldn’t have cared so much if I was risking our friendship. I lost it without saying a word.

So thank you, truly. You taught me never to doubt myself, hide my feelings or care to much about the opinion of someone else. It’s a lesson I’ll never forget.

So in the end the answer to the question “what could we have been?”

We could have been friends. Thought Catalog Logo Mark

More From Thought Catalog