Baking For Someone Who Doesn’t Love You Anymore

My sister has this recipe for chocolate-covered peanut butter bites that my family is crazy for. She bakes batches of them every Christmas and on this Valentine’s Day eve, I’m baking them for someone who doesn’t love me anymore. It wasn’t always like this but it is now and I guess what happened in the middle doesn’t matter.

Melt one stick of butter and stir in 32 ounces of crunchy peanut butter.

Valentine’s Day can be difficult to spend alone, but it can also be difficult for people who are in relationships. It can be difficult to locate the perfect spot on the wall behind him, the spot just over his left shoulder where you’ll stare during appetizers and main courses and desserts, where you’ll stare instead of making eye contact because you’re afraid of what you might see in those black holes on his face. Valentine’s Day can be a hard time to be thoughtful when all of your thoughts are, when will you admit it? When do we give up? When did this happen? When all of your thoughts are when when when, Valentine’s Day isn’t much fun.

Add ¾ box of confectioners sugar to help the ingredients stay together.

Baking isn’t much fun either, when the person you’re baking for will take this thing you’ve spent countless minutes, hours creating, this thing you wanted to perfect, this thing you loved; they will take it and destroy it in seconds and have no idea how much time, how much of yourself you had to sacrifice just for it to exist. Baking is hard, you know? It requires time and patience and muscle and measurements; it requires attention and aspiration and that’s why you shouldn’t bake for someone who no longer loves you.

Mix in four cups of rice krispies and refrigerate for one hour to keep things from falling apart.

I am realizing this now as my sink teems with dirty dishes, a ten-car pile-up of stainless steel; look at this mess I’ve made. I realize this when it’s 6 PM and he still hasn’t called, when I can’t remember the last time we spoke and there wasn’t that thing in his voice, that thing that screams DO IT SO I DON’T HAVE TO. I realize this when my best friend sends me a text message reading, “I’m engaged!” and I’m suddenly reminded those words will never be the ending to this story, that this story has ended already and the only question left is when when when. I wash my hands to congratulate her, to tell her I love her; I want so badly to wash my hands of this.

Roll mixture into bite-sized balls and melt chocolate in a double boiler. Cover the mixture in chocolate; cover it all up and refrigerate.

Tomorrow I will package the treats I’ve baked for him and I’ll wear something black and lacy beneath my dress and I’ll show up at his apartment. He’ll take what I’ve brought him and put it away without looking at it because Valentine’s Day is stupid and trivial and the first time he’s agreed to see me in over a week. He’ll take me to my favorite restaurant for what will be the last time and I’ll find the spot on the wall, just above his left shoulder, it’ll come easy because I’ve had lots of practice. The food will not taste as good as I remember and in three days, I will know the answer to the question when.

Serve cold. TC mark

image – Shutterstock


More From Thought Catalog

  • Amanda

    this is beautiful. 

  • Jessica

    Very well written January

  • Guest

    all of the sad. :(

  • Anonymous

    perfect ending perfect also its very well written

  • Anonymous

    + plus, i hope he chokes on that cake

  • Sophia

    oh my goodness this made me feel sick inside. i know this feeling all too well.

  • Mo

    this is such a good one. sucks it’s so good for the reason that it gives such a familiar feeling. but thank you for your stuff, miss. you should have spit in the mix. 

  • guest

    the last line! so good.

  • Anonymous

    Very haunting. It’s easy to forget that Valentine’s can be just as lonely/dark for couples as it is for some single people.

  • Laura

    Gave me that lump in your throat that makes it painful to swallow. So sad, beautifully written, and all too relatable.

  • Beth Buckley

    This happened to me this week.  My mocha fudge brownies went straight into his refrigerator.  He didn’t even eat them.

  • Guest

    This is one of the best articles I’ve read on ThoughtCatalog.

  • Chrissy Davey

    Gorgeously written.

  • Todd Clayton

    This is chilling.  And so, so pretty.

  • melly

    Probably the best TC I’ve read. The symbolism was beautiful, I’ve been through this same scenario and her words were hauntingly accurate

  • Wizzzmaster

    I want so badly to wash my hands of this”
    reminds me of Alanis Morissette’s “Hands Clean”
    some people don’t deserve our time, passion, feelings or even our cookies (which is very valuable)

  • Guest

    people dying in africa because of hunger/thirst, when i go to work i see people lying on the streets in -15 coz no shelter and all you care is how you feel while you are cooking cake for your valentine. whats going on this world!

    • hfg

      Just appreciate this piece of fiction just like you appreciate every meal you eat and every bit of warmth and shelter you are offered. There is no use in rudely criticizing someone’s writing simply because “people are dying in Africa”. Yes, people are dying EVERYWHERE, and yet, people are also living. You should try it sometime. 

  • Justin Kirkland4

    I’ve come back and read this at least three or four times since Valentine’s Day… such a beautiful, beautiful article. Truly.

  • AndreaCarmona

    This is one of the best articles I have read. So well written. And also I can relate very much.

  • Bake catalog | My2shoppe

    […] Baking For Someone Who Doesn’t Love You … – Thought CatalogSouthern Flavoring Catalog Request your. FREE Catalog ▻ · Perfect Accessories for all your. FALL BAKING ▻. Follow us on: Twitter Facebook … […]

  • 25 Things You Should Know About Love | Thought Catalog

    […] You will always have that one ex who will stick in your mind. They’ll feel like a perpetual dull ache in your […]

  • Only L<3Ve @

    […] You will always have that one ex who will stick in your mind. They’ll feel like a perpetual dull ache in your […]

  • Thought Catalog

    Reblogged this on Skirt.

  • 25 Things You Should Know About LoveDec. 11, 2012By | Just Janelle

    […] You will always have that one ex who will stick in your mind. They’ll feel like a perpetual dull ache in your […]

  • 25 Things You Should Know About Love (Repost) | this is JEN

    […] You will always have that one ex who will stick in your mind. They’ll feel like a perpetual dull ache in your […]

blog comments powered by Disqus