Thought Catalog

Sorry, An Epiphany Isn’t What’s Going To Change Your Life

  • 0
Steve Jurvetson
Steve Jurvetson

Epiphanies are bullshit. People think it’s some momentous wake up call that leads to innovation, identity crises, insight or breakthroughs.

Like that’s why someone “suddenly” quits the NFL. Or goes public with allegations. Or proposes a bold new theory about the world after staying up all night.

But the people who think that are mostly people who haven’t done anything like that. And probably never will. They haven’t had to walk away from a big job or a lot of money. Or ever questioned some dominant point of view or institution. Their creative output is next to nil. They’re too busy chasing (or waiting for) an El Dorado that doesn’t exist.

I get it. You want to be like the people you admire–and they all seem inspired, bold, and have no problem burning the place to ground. I wanted to be like that too.

But then I actually made some of those decisions. I dropped out of college and it was terrifying. I decided to write an expose about the media in which I would have to admit bad things I had done. I broke ranks with a mentor and friend and it’s been eating me up inside.

So lately, I’ve been trying to think about how that actually goes down. What is it actually like to come to question everything and change your mind or life? What do you need to know going into it?

In The Structure of Scientific Revolutions, Thomas Kuhn argued for the first time that it wasn’t flashes of brilliance that change scientific thinking, but instead it’s a slow process in which assumptions slowly unravel and then require a new explanation—a paradigm shift as he called it. In this frothy period of shift and flux, real breakthroughs begin to occur.

That isn’t how we like to imagine it though. We picture Edward Snowden hearing his bosses lay out some maniacal plan to spy on the world and deciding: “I am going to bring those motherfuckers down.” In actuality, he sat on the info for five years before going public. Doing what? Probably thinking, probably afraid, probably changing his mind a million times. It’s always more complicated—in fact, the whistleblower is usually complicit in the crimes in some way or at least blinded to their severity before coming forward.

The Fosbury Flop—which turned the Olympic High Jump on its head—wasn’t something that Dick Fosbury tried out for the first time at the 1968 Games. Nor was it something he was even certain about. Instead he’d been fooling with jumping and falling over the bar sideways as opposed to hurdling it since elementary school–to only middling results. He’d tried it high school and was told it was a “short cut to mediocrity.” He kept going back to way you were supposed to but that didn’t work either. As we know now though—after his Gold Medal and every medal since—that he was right and his technique stuck.

We think The Great Gatsby was a sniper shot of insight into the Jazz Age and its participants. In fact, the book was rejected and reworked by F. Scott Fitzgerald’s editor three times and only turned out to be right four years after publication, after the market crashed.

I think movies and television are partially responsible for this total misconception about the world. Because they can only show scenes, because they can’t get us inside the character’s head, we’ve started to think that’s how our lives should be. I think of that scene in Benjamin Button where Brad Pitt sneaks out one morning without a word and never comes back because he doesn’t want to burden his wife and family.

Yeah OK, like they would have been fighting for months and not known why. Like they wouldn’t have broached the topic or floated alternatives. Like the breakup would have stuck the first time. And he wouldn’t have been torn up inside and done a bunch of stupid things to cope with it. But as viewers all we’re left with is the action, the montage scene and the ultimate vindication, but not the process which precedes and proceeds it.

This is insidious because it intimidates first timers and the fearful. Because we believe that it must have been clear for other people, and yet it feels so opaque for us, we convince themselves not to take a risk. We doubt ourselves because we’re cut off from the humanness of the experience and the vulnerability that’s actually there.

When I wrote my first book, which was positioned as a confessional, every interviewer would ask me when I realized what I wanted to do. They’d say, “What was the thing you were asked to do that you regretted, that made you realize?”

The reality is never. I’m really struggling with it. It’s a fucking process. One that ironically didn’t even start to feel like it made sense until well into the writing and publishing process. Because that’s how people are, they act before they are fully ready and they figure things out as they go.

But I have to tell people something—so I give them an answer. Dropping out of college was the same thing. It was something I’d been considering, sure. Then I got an offer. Then I decided not to take it. Then I decided it was worth the risk. Almost immediately after, I felt it had been a mistake. But by then, I’d got into a rhythm. But a year later, I seriously considered going back. Yet my bio—my narrative—makes it seems like I knew at 19. (In fact, I turned 20 during the months this all transpired.) It’s not true, but that doesn’t help some other 19-year-old struggling with whether to leave college.

So if you’re staring some life changing decision in the face right now, you need to understand this. It is always going to be inscrutable. There will not be clarity. Not before, not during, not until well, well after.

You see, Thomas Kuhn said something else very wise and applicable here. Once a new paradigm takes hold, he said, it becomes almost impossible for people born into that paradigm to understand the logic of the system that came before them. As Kuhn put it, incommensurability separates one paradigm from the one that preceded it.

We can hardly recognize the world that we used to live in, and whatever it was that made us think the way we did. Because now things are radically different.

It would be nice if this was a clean break, but it isn’t. It’s like an internal Civil War—eventually there is a clear winner, but it didn’t feel that way at the time. It took a while for everything to get sorted out.

What I mean to say is this: embrace the limbo period. Take risk. Question things. Do not wait for certainty to act…because it isn’t coming. It never has. TC mark

Read This

More from Thought Catalog

Thought Catalog Videos


    • http://www.tradercabal.com/july-2nd-wednesday/ July 2nd Wednesday | The Cabal

      […] Action! not epiphany […]

    • http://elemonated.wordpress.com/2014/07/03/epiphanies/ Epiphanies | Pomelo girl thoughts

      […] Epiphanies […]

    • http://www.thumotic.com/really-happened-tucker-max/ What Really Happened To Tucker Max? - Thumotic

      […] His more talented friends are deserting him. […]

    • http://www.ryanholiday.net/my-2014-mid-year-writing-roundup/ My 2014 Mid-Year Writing Roundup | RyanHoliday.net

      […] Sorry, An Epiphany Isn’t What’s Going To Change Your Life – July 1 […]

    • https://thoughtcatalog.com/ryan-holiday/2014/08/3-stages-to-actually-knowing-what-youre-talking-about-where-are-you-on-the-path/ 3 Stages To Actually Knowing What You’re Talking About: Where Are You On The Path? | Thought Catalog

      […] learning about people, the lessons of life or just history, it doesn’t come easy. It doesn’t come in epiphanies. And this process–and whether we see it through–makes us who we […]

    • https://thoughtcatalog.com/ryan-holiday/2014/09/what-is-work-aversion-and-do-you-have-it/ What Is “Work Aversion,” And Do You Have It? | Thought Catalog

      […] Because when I said earlier that we have a fear of looking inward and doing something about it, I left a part out. It’s not just “something.” It’s a lot of things — it’s a long hard road, filled with tough decisions and difficult periods. There are no epiphanies. Remember? […]

    • http://djsohl.wordpress.com djsohl

      Reblogged this on Splinters and commented:
      Wow…. So exactly what I needed

    • https://thoughtcatalog.com/ryan-holiday/2014/10/passion-is-the-problem-not-the-solution/ Passion Is The Problem, Not The Solution | Thought Catalog

      […] in Jerry Maguire, how he has an epiphany and stays up all night in a passion-fueled frenzy writing his manifesto? What happens? He goes in […]

    • http://anthonysec.co/the-road-to-eldorado/ The Road to Eldorado | Anthony Secco

      […] Ryan Holiday‘s – Sorry, An Epiphany Isn’t What’s Going To Change Your Life […]

    • https://thoughtcatalog.com/ryan-holiday/2015/11/epiphanies-dont-exist-heres-how-you-can-actually-change-your-life-in-a-moment/ Epiphanies Don’t Exist, Here’s How You Can Actually Change Your Life In A Moment | Thought Catalog

      […] the title of this piece I said I don’t believe in epiphanies. I don’t. I’ve written before that I think they’re bullshit. And how is an epiphany different than a […]

    • http://thecontextofthings.com/2016/01/04/following-your-passion-could-be-the-actual-problem/ ‘Following your passion’ could be the actual problem | The Context Of Things

      […] in Jerry Maguire, how he has an epiphany and stays up all night in a passion-fueled frenzy writing his manifesto? What happens? He goes in […]

    • http://completenews.xyz/the-biggest-threat-to-your-success-is-the-story-you-tell-yourself-about-success The Biggest Threat to Your Success Is The Story You Tell Yourself About Success | completenews

      […] of: I hoped. I worked. I got some good breaks. Or even: I thought this could happen. Of course you didn’t really know all along—or if you did, it’s was more faith than knowledge. But who wants to remember all the times you […]

    blog comments powered by Disqus