Thought Catalog

This Is A List

  • 0

1)  The Beginning Of The List

The list begins. But what will it be a list of? Ten Real World Cast Members And What They’re Doing Now? The 20 Best 80s Jams Of All Time? Top 5 Disturbing Sexual Positions? Or will it be a list of something more obscure, like, What Your Favorite Vegetable Says About You?

In any case, there are only two possibilities with the list. Either you are interested in the topic, or — more intriguingly — you are not interested in the topic. If you have all of Real World: San Diego still preserved on pristine VHS tapes in your living room, then reading a list about that is a real no-brainer. But on the other hand, why would you want to read about what your favorite vegetable says about you? How will this information help you in any way? “But it’s a list, so it’s short,” you say to yourself without realizing that you are saying that to yourself.

2) The List Deepens

The deepening of the list. The initial heading… or numbered thingy on the list established the list, its joie de vivre, its raison d’être. But now, we plunge deeper into the ontology of the list. Sure, you learned from the first entry that Jacinda from Real World: London is a prostitute now, but the list must give you more. But… who are you, anyway?

3) The List Starts To Address You As A Whole

You are a person who likes things in lists. You would not want to read a whole essay about vegetables — all those blocks of text, so chunky — but if the information is presented in bite-sized form, you can handle that. You are the person standing next to his or her cupboard drawer, eating Keebler Chips Deluxe Peanut Butter Cups Cookies, one by one. You would not take the entire package of cookies to the dinner table, sit down, and eat them there; no, you would not do that — that’s a lot of commitment, plus, fattening. But you will eat the entire package of cookies one by one, while indecisively standing next to the cupboard.

So, that’s you. And is that our entire society, our entire culture right now? Luckily, this is a question that is beyond the purview of this list.

4) The List Starts To Disappoint You

Much like a person whose belly has been stuffed with too many Keebler Chips Deluxe Cookies, you start to feel bloated, and unsatisfied with the list. Are you really going to read all of this sh-t? No. Well, maybe just one more item on the listicle. …But perhaps the list will find other ways to charm you, to keep your interest. Like, embedded video content! Or, pictures! Pictures of things that you can recognize.

You greatly enjoy things that you can recognize.

5) The List Redeems Itself

Way to go, list! Good job, list! Good on ya, list! The list is like that guy “Rudy” in Rudy, redeeming itself like that. Why is the list redeeming itself? Because the list is almost over. You can see, by peering down the page, that the list is almost over. And you have read this far, so why not read a little more. Why not just actually finish something, for once in your god-curséd life? Why not indeed?

6) The End Of The List

The list has given you some laughs, some information, hopefully some things to reflect upon. Now, it is time for the list to exit. To exit gracefully, like a ballerina exiting gracefully from the stage. A way for the list to do this is with a mild joke. Unless the list is about something awful — “10 Groadiest Genocides.” In which case, maybe not.

Otherwise, the list will get out of this situation with a joke. Not an actual funny joke, mind you. More like a co-worker sort of joke. You know how, when you’re standing, talking to a co-worker at their cubicle, and you either need to go to the bathroom or go to lunch, which is what you were goddamn trying to do in the first place? So you seize a moment, perhaps a heightened moment in conversation, and say something that isn’t even funny, but you say it louder and in a “jokey” tone of voice. Like this:

Person one: Blah blah.

Person two: Blah.

Person one: Blah blah BLAH BLAH blah blah. Ha ha!

Person two: Ha ha!

Person one: Goodbye!

Person two: Bye!

…And so that is how the list makes its exit. With a “not-joke” joke. It’s not really funny, but you recognize it as being a joke. And so, that is how the list leaves you; not with a bang, but with a whimper. TC mark

Author’s note:  The author originally wrote this article on June 28th, according to the composition history that is saved with each article. Then he thought, hey, maybe for once in his life, he should shop an article around, maybe try to make a little more money for an article? So he didn’t publish this essay and then on July 6th, a Mr. Tao Lin published an article on Thought Catalog that was very similar to this article, except that this article is funnier than his article, but still, the author screamed in frustration when he saw that. AAAAAAAAAAH, he screamed.

So, two conclusions may be drawn from all of this: (1) The author was justifiably punished for his authorial greed and hubris. (2) This article was meant to satirize the over-abundance of lists, but now it’s part of an over-abundance of lists satirizing other lists — which is… irony? But not the literary definition of irony; more like the Alanis Morissette definition of irony, which is how we all use the word “irony” now anyway — language is fluid, people, and we don’t use “irony” in the 19th century manner anymore; so maybe everyone could just adjust to that, and stop saying “But that’s not REALLY irony” whenever that song comes on, which, it doesn’t come on much anymore, but still. Anyway, the meaning of irony has changed, is what I was saying. Also I got screwed, is what I was saying. So in conclusion, the author would like to apologize for all of this, especially for this author’s note.


Powered by Revcontent

Severe(d): A Creepy Poetry Collection

I used to get butterflies when I looked at you, but now they feel more like maggots feasting away on the heart you slaughtered.

More From Thought Catalog

  • Anonymouse

    this was a really poor attempt at satirizing tao lin’s article

    • http://www.facebook.com/oliveramiller Oliver Miller

      You didn’t read the author’s note.

  • Michael

    The meaning of irony hasn’t changed. The way that it’s used (rimarily by idiots) has.

    • https://thoughtcatalog.com/ Oliver Miller

      But that’s how word meanings change, when people start using words differently. For example, the word “lady” means “loaf-kneader,” i.e., maker of bread, i.e., servile woman stuck in the kitchen…in the original 5th century Anglo-Saxon, that what’s it means. (“Lord” means “loaf owner,” by the way, if you’re interested.) We use “lady” to mean something different now, as we’re generally starting to use “irony” to mean something different now, is my point.

      • Michael

        That’s different. That one example you came up with has evolved over god knows how long. The word irony, however, has been misused by hipsters over the past decade (probably less) because they think they sound intelligent when they use it.

    • Jami

      Whaaaa? Connotations are more fluid in the 21st century? What could possibly be a vehicle for that change? Couldn’t be that we have more instantaneous communication.

  • PB

    I feel like you’re beating the whole “I’m going to write a snarky article satirizing TC’s frequent lists” thing to death. Something new would be appreciated. Thanks.

  • http://twitter.com/brad_pike Brad Pike (@brad_pike)

    I never read Tao Lin’s article, but I enjoyed this one. These other commenters sound lonely. Poor commenters. They need the negativity squeezed out of them like fat lonely zits.

    • Drew

      Yet Oliver Miller’s articles (and comments for that matter- take a gander at the comment section of his last article) are chock-full of negativity. You and the author need the pretentiousness squeezed out of you like fat snobbish zits.

  • Elly

    I am still hoping you don’t come to Canada. You’re basically the angry, jealous hipster of TC that tries to turn that bitterness into awkward humor.

    • https://thoughtcatalog.com/ Oliver Miller

      It’s a big country, honey; we’ll be fine.

    • psstop

      So true, Elly. And the author’s response only confirms what you wrote.

      • https://thoughtcatalog.com/ Oliver Miller

        I am sorry that my response to her stream of insults did not redeem me in your eyes.

      • psstop

        Ewww…and you just keep digging yourself deeper…

      • https://thoughtcatalog.com/ Oliver Miller

        I’m sure you would handle having a bunch of strangers writing bizarre personal insults in response to a humor column in a much… smoother manner. Actually, let me break character for a second. All joking aside, Elly and others of her ilk try to get me mad by repeatedly insulting me on a personal level, and this is done in response to humor columns, which is a reaction that is fairly insane on their part. I handle it just fine, despite your failed attempts to insinuate that I don’t. Thanks, chief.

    • Dottedlinedolores

      Isn’t that article two weeks old by now? That’s like a year in internet time, so you seriously need to chill if you’re still this mad about it.

  • Rishtopher

    I actually really like list articles. Yeah, they give me bite-sized chunks of info that I can quickly read and I like that because I often have at least 10-15 articles scattered across various websites that I’m trying to get through, one by one.

    It’s the information age; they want things that are to-the-point and the faster, the better.

    • http://www.facebook.com/oliveramiller Oliver Miller

      I am not against all lists, don’t get me wrong. I like a good list as much as the next guy. I am against overuse of lists, is all. I am fairly against the ‘How To’ articles at this point, although there are definite occasional good ones; but hey, they’re not for me, so.

  • scott laudati

    I thought the irony was fantastic.

  • RAH

    “deeper into the ontology of the list” – hahaahhahahah that’s hysterical i love you oliver

  • Sanjana

    I like the hidden references!! Magritte for “This is not a pipe” and Elliot are the ones I got, but i feel like there may be more hidden in there. :)

    Also, “You greatly enjoy things that you can recognize.” reminds me of Eddie Izzard. XD

    • http://www.facebook.com/oliveramiller Oliver Miller

      I usually try to do hidden references, but the Magritte thing didn’t occur to me at all, even though, yes, I see it now. Eliot actually really hated that quote, because it was the only thing most people remembered that he wrote, sort of how like bands start hating their most popular songs because they have to play them all the time, kind of thing.

  • Hry

    Apology accepted. Just don’t let it happen again.

  • ricky

    mmmm my boner for oliver miller has gotten so big that it’s started writing its own lists, daaaaang

  • Boolio

    Hipsters use the back door. Or don’t come in at all

  • Boolio

    Also, though, this list had me thinking of Perd Hapley the whole time. anyone?

  • http://slacktory.com/2012/07/data-points-these-are-some-data-points/ Data Points: These Are Some Data Points | Slacktory | This seems legit.

    […] “You would not want to read a whole essay about vegetables — all those blocks of text, so chunky — but if the information is presented in bite-sized form, you can handle that.” — “This is a list” by Slacktory contributor Oliver Miller. [Thought Catalog] […]

  • Svenry

    Hm, no “Title of the Song” references? I am disappoint.

  • https://thoughtcatalog.com/2012/why-i-write/ Why I Write | Thought Catalog

    […] clever, funny, or dramatic, but it at least has the advantage of being very, very simple. For the last essay that I wrote, I had this stuck in my head: “You greatly enjoy things that you can […]

  • http://www.itmakesmestronger.com/2012/07/why-i-write/ Only L<3Ve @ ItMakesMeStronger.com

    […] clever, funny, or dramatic, but it at least has the advantage of being very, very simple. For the last essay that I wrote, I had this stuck in my head: “You greatly enjoy things that you can […]

  • https://thoughtcatalog.com/2013/im-done-with-thought-catalog/ I’m Done With Thought Catalog | Thought Catalog

    […] started predictably enough. Those things that I once found cute became so reoccurring, so banal. And at the forefront came the lists. They no longer stimulated the muscles in my cheeks to curl my mouth into a small smile. Rather […]

blog comments powered by Disqus