Thought Catalog

Censorship Is Perfectly Unnatural

  • 0

8519893720_9bae28bf93_o

“When you tear out a man’s tongue, you are not proving him a liar, you’re only telling the world that you fear what he might say.” -Tyrion Lannister

If there’s one thing that I’ll never understand, it’s the desire to suppress speech instead of allowing it to be aired and judged for itself in the great American marketplace of ideas.  One recent case that should be familiar to Thought Catalog readers is that of Gavin McInnes, who is currently on an indefinite leave of absence after tolerance lynch mobs relentlessly attacked him for his Thought Catalog article “Transphobia Is Perfectly Natural“, which has now been hidden behind a warning due to its “abusive” content.  Now, I’m not defending Gavin’s article (I won’t comment on it one way or the other), but what, exactly, is accomplished by this censorship?

Censors typically censor speech because they fear what is being said – in this case, one can presume that the PC brigade fears that the article will turn its readers into “transphobes”.  But, if the article is truly as disgusting and hateful and outrageous as its critics have claimed, then wouldn’t it actually have the opposite effect on readers?  Wouldn’t it actually turn them against “transphobia”, thus making it in their best interests not to censor it, but to instead ensure that it’s seen by a large audience?

Another recent case that demonstrates this point quite well is the case of a Times of Israel blog posting titled “When Genocide is Permissible” by Yochanan Gordon, which was immediately pulled after it was posted and sparked a huge outrage, particularly on Twitter, where it briefly trended.  Palestinian activists are known to frequently accuse Israel of committing genocide, yet, when an Israeli writer comes out and flat-out advocates for genocide in Gaza, they’re eager to censor him and shut him up.  Why?  If anything, they should consider it a blessing – it’s hard to imagine anything helping their side more than an Israeli writer vindicating their point so well by writing a pro-genocide editorial.  With his column, Gordon effectively turned people against Israel far better than any black propaganda ever could.  If pro-Palestinian activists were using any sort of common sense and/or logic here, they would be loudly encouraging pro-Israeli activists to advocate genocide blatantly and frequently.

australian-libertarian

I am well aware of the fact that the First Amendment only protects against government censorship and not against private censorship, but this does not change the fact that private censorship tends to be utterly senseless and counter-intuitive in and of itself (the Australian imbecile in the screenshot above ironically demonstrates the failure of censorship in the first section of his pro-censorship tirade).  If a writer whom I despised wrote an article foaming at the mouth about how all Jews should be exterminated, the last thing that I’d want to do would be to censor that writer.  To the contrary, in fact – I would spread the article far and wide and encourage the writer to put out more articles just like it (perhaps even more offensive ones).  Nothing else would do more damage to the writer – and to anti-Semitism in general – than to have their outrageous views heard by a large audience.  Alex Linder certainly hasn’t done any favors to the neo-Nazi movement with his frequent, explicit calls for violence and genocide, and there’s a reason why FBI informants like Hal Turner often use such over-the-top rhetoric when posing as white supremacists: it discredits the racist movement, makes racists look bad, and even drives away people who would otherwise be perfectly comfortable with open racism.

chaim-kikeburgstein

People are not braindead, glassy-eyed automatons who mindlessly accept absolutely everything that they read or hear without even thinking about it.  People respond positively to well-thought-out, persuasive, and reasonable arguments – not to crude, obnoxious, and offensive vitriol.  Why encourage people that you hate to express views that you loathe in a civil and reasonable way rather than in a crass and despicable way?  On top of that, attempting to silence speech does not get rid of the viewpoint being expressed – if anything, it has the exact opposite effect, as both Gavin McInnes and Yochanan Gordon have gotten infinitely more exposure than they ever would have had if not for the outraged online mobs hounding them.  In addition, McInnes has now been transformed into something of a martyr figure, thus strengthening the “transphobic” views of those who may be drawn to sympathize with him.  If you want to defeat someone’s speech, defeat it with speech of your own.  Attempting to forcibly silence it only demonstrates to the public that you can’t defeat it and are thus trying to prevent people from hearing it lest they be convinced by it.  Censorship always helps the censored, and it’s about time for people to learn that.  Censorship is perfectly unnatural. TC mark

featured image – Flickr Commons – zharth

Read This

More from Thought Catalog

Thought Catalog Videos


    • http://moonmetropolis.wordpress.com/2014/11/14/europe-never-learns/ Europe Never Learns | MoonMetropolis

      […] Censorship is, to quote the American Civil Liberties Union (ACLU), “like poison gas: a powerful weapon that can harm you when the wind shifts.” For a good recent example, Japanese politicians have proposed using new “hate speech” laws in Japan – which the United Nations and “human rights activists” and other useful idiots have repeatedly demanded (even though much of the “hate speech” in Japan could simply be prosecuted as harassment and/or intimidation) – in order to silence anti-government and anti-nuclear protests since, in the words of Japanese politician Sanae Takaichi, lawmakers need to work “without any fear of criticism” (laws against “hate speech” in Japan could, ironically, also be used to shut down the very same pro-North Korean schools that Japanese racists want to be closed, thus giving the racists exactly what they want). Orwellian newspeak and doublethink are staples of the “human rights” lobby, as exemplified by “human rights advocate” Yoshifu Arita’s statement: “I would venture to say that we need to restrict hate speech in order to protect freedom of speech.” […]

    • https://thoughtcatalog.com/joshua-goldberg/2014/11/why-censoring-speech-creates-extremists-and-causes-atrocities-instead-of-stopping-them/ Why Censoring Speech Creates Extremists And Causes Atrocities Instead Of Stopping Them | Thought Catalog

      […] Censorship is, to quote the American Civil Liberties Union (ACLU), “like poison gas: a powerful weapon that can harm you when the wind shifts.” For a good recent example, Japanese politicians have proposed using new “hate speech” laws in Japan – which the United Nations and “human rights activists” and other useful idiots have repeatedly demanded (even though much of the “hate speech” in Japan could simply be prosecuted as harassment and/or intimidation) – in order to silence anti-government and anti-nuclear protests since, in the words of Japanese politician Sanae Takaichi, lawmakers need to work “without any fear of criticism” (laws against “hate speech” in Japan could, ironically, also be used to shut down the very same pro-North Korean schools that Japanese racists want to be closed, thus giving the racists exactly what they want). Orwellian newspeak and doublethink are staples of the “human rights” lobby, as exemplified by “human rights advocate” Yoshifu Arita’s statement: “I would venture to say that we need to restrict hate speech in order to protect freedom of speech.” Of course, many of the very same people who are demanding that Japanese Prime Minister Shinzo Abe and his Liberal Democratic Party take steps to outlaw “hate speech” are also outraged at his stated intentions to change the Japanese Constitution and limit freedom of speech by making certain vaguely-defined kinds of speech “contrary to public order” and consider this to be the sign of a coming police state – even though “hate speech” has been used as a justification for Abe’s plans. The level of mental gymnastics from pro-censorship advocates truly is a sight to behold. […]

    • http://moonmetropolis.wordpress.com/2014/12/01/when-social-justice-warriors-attack-one-tumblr-users-experience/ When Social Justice Warriors Attack: One Tumblr User’s Experience | MoonMetropolis

      […] by name, Ashley Rae Goldenberg started the Tumblr blog Communismkills in 2011. In a manner that I’ve written about many times <a […]

    • https://thoughtcatalog.com/joshua-goldberg/2014/12/when-social-justice-warriors-attack-one-tumblr-users-experience/ When Social Justice Warriors Attack: One Tumblr User’s Experience | Thought Catalog

      […] by name, Ashley Rae Goldenberg started the Tumblr blog Communismkills in 2011. In a manner that I’ve written about many times before, Ashley’s blog was made popular by people voicing their anger at her and […]

    • http://all.theglobalpoint.com/2014/12/how-social-justice-warriors-are-creating-an-entire-generation-of-fascists/ How Social Justice Warriors Are Creating An Entire Generation Of Fascists | The Global Point

      […] by name, Ashley Rae Goldenberg started the Tumblr blog Communismkills in 2011. In a manner that I’ve written about many times before, Ashley’s blog was made popular by people voicing their anger at her and […]

    • http://moonmetropolis.wordpress.com/2015/01/04/hate-speech-hysteria-spreads-to-japan/ “Hate Speech” Hysteria Spreads to Japan | MoonMetropolis

      […] someone holds hateful and despicable views, then the best thing you can possibly do is to encourage them to make those views as widely known as possi….  In the US – where people are free to speak their minds openly – there have been […]

    • https://moonmetropolis.wordpress.com/2015/01/14/freedom-of-speech-shouldnt-be-driven-down-under/ Freedom of Speech Shouldn’t Be Driven Down Under | MoonMetropolis

      […] it to the sunlight where it will die. The more vile, extreme, and outrageous the bigotry is, the more it drives people away and makes bigots look bad. The only logical way to deal with hatred is to defeat it in a free […]

    • https://thoughtcatalog.com/joshua-goldberg/2015/02/hate-speech-hysteria-spreads-to-japan/ “Hate Speech” Hysteria Spreads to Japan | Thought Catalog

      […] someone holds hateful and despicable views, then the best thing you can possibly do is to encourage them to make those views as widely known as possi…. To quote the free speech activist Harvey Silverglate, “you want to know who openly hates you […]

    • https://thoughtcatalog.com/joshua-goldberg/2015/02/freedom-of-speech-shouldnt-be-driven-down-under/ Freedom Of Speech Shouldn’t Be Driven Down Under | Thought Catalog

      […] it to the sunlight where it will die. The more vile, extreme, and outrageous the bigotry is, the more it drives people away and makes bigots look bad.  Having bigots air their disgusting views in public only serves to […]

    • http://hotviralnow.com/freedom-of-speech-shouldnt-be-driven-down-under.html Freedom Of Speech Shouldn’t Be Driven Down Under | Hot Viral Now

      […] it to the sunlight where it will die. The more vile, extreme, and outrageous the bigotry is, the more it drives people away and makes bigots look bad.  Having bigots air their disgusting views in public only serves to […]

    blog comments powered by Disqus