My Horribly Embarrassing Saturday Night With Friends (That Ended Up In An Orgy)

I’ve been wanting to share this story with someone for a while, but it’s too embarrassing to tell without being anonymous. I’m sure a lot of you guys will find this story hot or sexy, but I still shy away when anyone brings it up.

This happened about two years ago. I was a freshman girl in college, and I already met a big group of friends. We all had only known each other a few months, as we were in our second semester. The last Saturday before finals began we decided to rent a cheap cottage on the beach to party.

*

Everyone arrived late afternoon on Saturday. Including myself there were eight of us. Six guys, two girls. I didn’t like many of the girls, so I stuck to my group of guy friends, and the only other girl with us was my good friends Rachel.

We started drinking as soon as we got there, and by 8 PM we we’re pretty drunk. I’m a lightweight, but I drank more that night than I ever had. Rachel and I had never hooked up with any of the guys in our group before, and we really never talked about it. My friends’ nickname for me was Mousey, because I am kinda shy, a little quiet, and extremely petite. Like 4’11”, 100 lbs. petite. Because of this, most of the guys in the group flirted with Rachel more. They would occasionally call me cute, adorable, etc., but nothing more than that.

So we drank, talked, and danced a little until about 10 p.m. I was so drunk I broke out of my shy and quiet shell, and was instead loud and making jokes. None of my friends had seen me like this and they were all having a blast. My friend Jake suggested we play flip cup. Without thinking, I blurted out asking what the losing team had to do. Everyone kinda paused, then my other friend Mike shouted that the losers had to play the next game in their underwear. Even though I was drunk, I hesitated at the thought of being in my underwear around all my guy friends. No one spoke up, so it was agreed upon, to my reluctance.

There were three guys on each team—and Rachel and I on opposite teams, so it was four on four. The game came right down to the last person, but sadly we lost. As soon as the other team finished, they started to chant: take it off, take it off! I half-jokingly begged, saying something like, “Pleaseeee do I have to!?” And of course all the guys were saying I had to. I took my top off at first, and every guys face went straight to my boobs. They aren’t very big at all because I’m so small, but there’s at least a little something there. In case anyone is wondering, I’m a size 32 B. Then came the pants. Oh the pants.

They were so tight around me, and I was stumbling all over trying to pull them off, but they wouldn’t budge. One of the guys told me to sit on the couch so he could pull them off for me. Already embarrassed, I sit down. Soon there are three guys yanking and pulling the legs of my pants, while another guy tries pulling my pants off from the waist. After a little bit of a struggle they came off. What I didn’t know was they caught the top of underwear as well, and as fast as the pants came off, so did my undies.

Now imagine laying down on a couch with both legs in the air, and being completely bottomless. Well, that was me. I didn’t even notice for a few seconds because I was so drunk. One of the guys shouted something like, oh my God, she lost her underwear! That’s when I noticed and pretty much died inside. As I demanded my underwear back from the guy holding them he told me that I had the thickest bush he’s ever seen. I’m so hairy down there and I hadn’t shaved for a few weeks. As I put my underwear back on, all my guy friends were trying to console me, telling me, don’t worry it’s not that bad, we’re all friends. Meanwhile my friend Rachel was dying, laughing at how funny the situation was.

The night went on, and because I had been drinking more, I basically had forgotten about what had happened. I even started to laugh about it. I was practically bragging about how lucky they were to see me with my pants off. At one point I even said I’m not scared to be naked! All the guys immediately went quiet, and one of them said to prove it. This is when I realized what I had just said. I tried to back out, saying, “No not in front of my friends!” They of course made chicken noises, and were just egging me on. Rachel even said jokingly, “Mousey almost cried when her undies fell off,” laughing the entire time she spoke. Everyone was laughing along with her.

To this day I regretted my next decision so much. I still don’t know why I did it. Without thinking I took off everything. As soon as the underwear came off I knew I had made a big mistake. I turned so red and wanted to run away, but something wouldn’t let me. Every guy at once was commenting on my butt, my boobs, etc. Than I started to call everyone else a chicken. So after a little bit, we were all completely naked and drunk in the cottage. It was the most embarrassing moment for me, but it was also really surreal. Then we all ran out of the cottage and onto the beach, skinny dipping in the ocean. Rachel taking pictures and videos the entire time we were out there.

When we returned to the cottage, things got WAY too out of control and went WAY too fast. Everyone stayed naked and we sat around on the floor in a big circle. Everyone was sharing sex stories, and telling really personal details. Rachel and I even measured all their dicks to see who was the biggest. I’m so drunk I felt like I didn’t care, but in the back of my mind the whole time I was freaking out in embarrassment. One of the guys shouted out that he was horny, kind of in a joking, but half-serious manner. I got really nervous by that point, because I knew something was probably going to happen. Then another one said we should have some fun.

There were six guys and only us two girls. Rachel and I looked at each other like, this is so awkward, but we could see it in each others’ eyes—we were both really horny as well. A few more words were exchanged and the next thing I know Rachel is jerking off two of our guy friends at once, while a third is starting to finger her. I blurted out, “Oh my God! Guys this is so weird! It’s like a porn video right now!” One of the other guys came closer to me and just asked if I was horny. I didn’t really respond to him, just kinda nodded a little and whispered that this felt weird. He started to play with my butt and boobs, and all the other guys were yelling out “Oh my God! Mousey!!” Just then I turned so red, but being touched also felt so good. Than I felt a finger slip right inside me. I let out an uncontrollable moan, and all the guys stopped and just watched me. Even Rachel stopped. Three other guys came over, and now I had four of my friends squeezing, touching, and fingering me. One of them put me on my stomach and everyone started to grab my butt. Then I was lifted just a little bit, so I was bent over on my knees, legs spread apart. I felt so many fingers inside me from behind I was moaning and panting so much. I heard one of the guys say he could see my tiny asshole, and I went back to panicking. Just hearing that and knowing they were looking at it was so embarrassing. Then, before I could reposition myself, one of the guys stuck a finger inside it. I tightened up so much. This continued on for what seemed like hours.

It soon turned into me and Rachel being shared between all of our friends. They kept asking the whole time if we were okay with it, and truthfully we wanted it badly by then. All of our friends got to fuck us both, and they all came on our bodies. We eventually all fell asleep that night and awoke to everything that had just taken place the night before. I was so embarrassed and shy, but all the guys were assuring us it stayed between our little group. Every time I talk to my friends now I always picture that Saturday night. It went so fast and so crazy most of us still can’t believe it happened.

Tl;Dr: Went to cottage on beach with friends, got naked and had big orgy, and still embarrassed about it all. Thought Catalog Logo Mark

Republished, with a little editing, from r/gonewildstories with the permission of the author, u/Alexy910.

thumbnail image – Alagich Katya

Related

More From Thought Catalog