Thought Catalog

I Am Not Your Wife, Sister Or Daughter. I Am A Person.

  • 0
US National Archives
US National Archives

I don’t have to tell you that Steubenville is all over the news.

I don’t have to tell you that the fact that Trent Mays and Ma’lik Richmond, the two teenagers convicted of raping a sixteen year old girl, were only sentenced to a combined three years in juvenile prison, is a fucking joke. Each will serve a year for the rape itself; Mays will serve an additional year for “illegal use of a minor in nudity-oriented material.”

I probably don’t even have to tell you that the media treatment of this trial has been a perfect, if utterly sickening, example of rape culture, with its focus on how difficult and painful this event has been for the rapists who raped a sixteen year old girl then bragged about it on social media.

And I almost certainly don’t have to tell you that the world is full of seemingly nice, normal people who want to go to bat for the convicted rapists. I’m quite sure that you already know about the victim-blaming that’s been happening since this case first came to light. You know about the fact that people have actually come out and said that the real lesson to be learned here is that we need to be more careful with social media (i.e. go ahead and rape but make sure you don’t get caught). You already know that people seem to think that being a sports star and having a good academic record should somehow make up for the fact that you are a rapist.

I don’t have to tell you any of that because it’s all par for the course.

What I do want to tell you is that you need to stop using the “wives, sisters, daughters” argument when you are talking to people defending the Steubenville rapists. Or any rapists. Or anyone who commits any kind of crime, violent or otherwise, against a woman.

In case you’re unfamiliar with this line of rhetoric, it’s the one that goes like this:

You should stop defending the rapists and start caring about the victim. Imagine if she was your sister, or your daughter, or your wife. Imagine how badly you would feel if this happened to a woman that you cared about.

Framing the issue this way for rape apologists can seem useful. I totally get that. It feels like you’re humanizing the victim and making the event more relatable, more sympathetic to the person you’re arguing with.

You know what, though? Saying these things is not helpful; in fact, it’s not even helping to humanize the victim. What you are actually doing is perpetuating rape culture by advancing the idea that a woman is only valuable in so much as she is loved or valued by a man.

The Steubenville rape victim was certainly someone’s daughter. She may have been someone’s sister. Someday she might even be someone’s wife. But these are not the reasons why raping her was wrong. This rape, and any rape, was wrong because women are people. Women are people, rape is wrong, and no one should ever be raped. End of story.

The “wives, sisters, daughters” line of argument comes up all the fucking time. President Obama even used it in his State of the Union address this year, saying,

“We know our economy is stronger when our wives, mothers, and daughters can live their lives free from discrimination in the workplace, and free from the fear of domestic violence.”

This device, which Obama has used on more than one occasion, is reductive as hell. It defines women by their relationships to other people, rather than as people themselves. It says that women are only important when they are married to, have given birth to, or have been fathered by other people. It says that women are only important because of who they belong to.

Women are not possessions.

Women are people.

I seriously cannot believe that I have to say this in 2013.

On top of all of this, I want you to think of a few other implications this rhetorical device has. For one thing, what does it say about the women who aren’t anyone’s wife, mother or daughter? What does it say about the kids who are stuck in the foster system, the kids who are shuffled from one set of foster parents to another or else living in a group home? What does it say about the little girls whose mothers surrender them, willingly or not, to the state? What does it say about the people who turn their back on their biological families for one reason or another?

That they deserve to be raped? That they are not worthy of protection? That they are not deserving of sympathy, empathy or love?

And when we frame all women as being someone’s wife, mother or daughter, what are we teaching young girls?

We are teaching them that in order to have the law on their side, they need to be loved by men. That they need to make themselves attractive and appealing to men in order to be worthy of protection. That their lives and their bodily integrity are valueless except for how they relate to the men they know.

The truth is that I am someone’s wife. I am also someone’s mother. I am someone’s daughter, and someone’s sister. But those are not the things that define me, or make me valuable in this world. Those are not the reasons that I should be able to live a life free from rape, sexual assault or any kind of violent crime.

I have value because I am a person. Full stop. End of argument. This isn’t even a discussion that we should be having.

So please, let’s start teaching that fact to the young women in our lives. Teach them that you love, honour and value them because of who they are. Teach them that they should expect to be treated with integrity because it’s a basic human right. Teach them that they do not deserve to be raped because no one ever, ever, ever deserves to be raped.

Above all, teach them that they are people, too. TC Mark

Read This

More from Thought Catalog

Thought Catalog Videos


    • Thought Catalog

      Reblogged this on shemustchallenge.

    • Thought Catalog

      Reblogged this on Quote of the Dazes and commented:
      very well written piece

    • Thought Catalog

      Reblogged this on mollyapfelroth and commented:
      Just absolute perfection in writing. Yes.

    • http://bellejarblog.wordpress.com/2013/03/23/on-writing-fiction/ On Writing Fiction | The Belle Jar

      […] that it’s fact. And yes, I Am Not Your Wife was reposted to the The Believer’s tumblr, Thought Catalog, The Frisky, and Huffington Post, and yes, those things are huge, but I still don’t feel […]

    • http://lostinthecorn.radiofubar.com/?p=143 Lost In The Corn » #118: Fuck Patriarchy, Rapists, and Douchebags

      […] about Steubenville. Rape culture discussions abound. This picture will ruin your day. Also, a redefinition of why it’s terrible to rape people. Henry Rollins NAILS it! Also, talking about Zerlina Maxwell getting racist rape […]

    • https://thoughtcatalog.com/2013/178091/ I Feel Sorry For The Steubenville Rapists | Thought Catalog

      […] couldn’t even call her abuse “rape.” I feel sorry that she needs to be seen as someone’s wife or daughter to understand that we should not rape her and that her self-worth isn’t tied to her intrinsic […]

    • http://www.itmakesmestronger.com/2013/03/i-feel-sorry-for-the-steubenville-rapists/ Only L<3Ve @ ItMakesMeStronger.com

      […] couldn’t even call her abuse “rape.” I feel sorry that she needs to be seen as someone’s wife or daughter to understand that we should not rape her and that her self-worth isn’t tied to her intrinsic […]

    • http://alicestonehousefap.wordpress.com/2013/10/10/protest-art/ Protest Art | Alice Stonehouse FeministArtPower
    • http://kamenasoutien.com/2014/02/09/galliko-film-se3ismou/ “Αντίστροφος σεξισμός” α λα γαλλικά –

      […] – I Am Not Your Wife, Sister Or Daughter. I Am A Person. | Thought Catalog […]

    • http://www.fylosykis.gr/2014/02/%ce%b1%ce%bd%cf%84%ce%af%cf%83%cf%84%cf%81%ce%bf%cf%86%ce%bf%cf%82-%cf%83%ce%b5%ce%be%ce%b9%cf%83%ce%bc%cf%8c%cf%82-%ce%b1-%ce%bb%ce%b1-%ce%b3%ce%b1%ce%bb%ce%bb%ce%b9%c “Αντίστροφος σεξισμός” α λα γαλλικά : Fylosykis.gr

      […] I Am Not Your Wife, Sister Or Daughter. I Am A Person. | Thought […]

    • http://amandabales.wordpress.com/2014/08/05/the-nose-pickers-daughter-wife/ The Nose Picker’s Daughter-Wife | amandabales

      […] No it isn’t. Just in case there is any doubt, you can hear a kid in the Stubenville video ask this, and the […]

    • http://www.whyfeminist.com/2014/07/22/shes-not-just-someones-daughter/ SHE’S NOT (JUST) SOMEONE’S DAUGHTER | Why Feminist

      […] the idea that women are only valuable because of their relation to other people, usually men. Instead, we should treat women with dignity because they are people.  Anne Theriault lays out why this is so […]

    • http://goodmenproject.com/featured-content/teaching-brother-boys-patriarchies-masculinities-man-wat/ Teaching My Brother and Other Boys About Patriarchies, Masculinities and Being a Man -

      […] I am not saying that like people say that we should care about women’s rights because they are “mothers, daughters, sisters and wives.” I care about his relationship with masculinity not because he is related to me somehow and I […]

    • http://selfhelpeducationarena.com/teaching-my-brother-and-other-boys-about-patriarchies-masculinities-and-being-a-man-the-good-men-project/ Teaching My Brother and Other Boys About Patriarchies, Masculinities and Being a Man - The Good Men Project - Self Help Education Arena

      […] I am not saying that like people say that we should care about women’s rights because they are “mothers, daughters, sisters and wives.” I care about his relationship with masculinity not because he is related to me somehow and I […]

    • https://rachelshawley.wordpress.com/2016/08/03/rape-culture-is-a-mans-issue-too/ Rape Culture is a Man’s Issue, Too – Gender, Sexuality & New Media

      […] at night because he has daughters and understands the fear he must have inflicted.  But there are lots of others who have called bullshit on this type of appeal to men.  You don’t have to have a […]

    • http://stellingdames.nl/een-vrouw-is-een-mens-niet-alleen-je-moeder-dochter-zus-of-vriendin/ Een vrouw is een mens – niet alleen je moeder, dochter, zus of vriendin | Stellingdames

      […] “What you are actually doing is perpetuating rape culture by advancing the idea that a woman is only valuable in so much as she is loved or valued by a man.” – Anne Thériault […]

    • https://dezesdeclan.wordpress.com/2017/03/26/verzetsheldin-verandert-in-de-vrouw-van/ Verzetsheldin verandert in ‘de vrouw van’ | De Zesde Clan

      […] in de V.S. routinematig over vrouwen in de zin van ‘dochter/echtgenote van’. Ze reduceren vrouwen tot een onderdeel van een relatie met een man. Alleen als het gaat om een dochter of vrouw van, kunnen deze mannen zich voorstellen dat het erg […]

    blog comments powered by Disqus