You’re Going To Break My Heart

Nov. 3, 2011
Ryan O’Connell is a 25 year-old writer based in the East Village, New York.

You’re going to break my heart. Smash Cut: Me being rushed into emergency surgery to repair it. Smash Cut: Me on the floor of my bedroom listening to The Stone Roses or maybe “Across The Universe” on repeat. Smash Cut: Me wanting to kill you, preferably during sex.

That’s okay though. A full heart is overrated anyway. On some level, I don’t mind having a broken because it reminds me that I’m alive and that stuff is happening in my life. The worst is an unattended heart. It’s not full, it’s not empty; it’s just there. That kind of make you feel like you’re dead inside and everything is just stagnant. The worst.

The moment I realized you were going to break my heart was when we were lying in bed together that one Sunday afternoon. The windows were open in my room and I could feel it tickling my toes like someone was blowing on them for fun. This was in the house I lived in for nine months on Curson, the house where everything started and fell apart for us. It smelled liked lavender incense that day and I remember holding you tight in bed, almost like I was a Boa Constrictor who was going to crush your bones. I started to sense some resistance on your end though. Your body just hung there like a limp rag doll and that’s when I realized that you were rejecting me. I was being rejected on a day where everything was supposed to feel close and that’s when I understood that this relationship was living on borrowed time. That’s when I knew you were not going to break my heart but that you were actually breaking my heart.

It’s amazing what you’ll turn a blind eye to. It’s amazing how many Sundays you can endure with a limp rag doll. The more you can get rejected, the more you want to prove yourself. You pull all the tricks you got out of your little hat. “Will this make you love me? Will this make you love me? What about THIS?”

In retrospect, I guess I always knew I was going to love you more. It’s something you feel from the very beginning, something you implicitly understand but try to ignore. You know the dynamics of a relationship from the beginning. I signed the contract saying, “I promise to love you more and feel slighted by your coldness. Signed, sealed, delivered. Baby, I’m yours.”

So here we are. Who woulda guessed it? Oh yeah, me. I ignored the signs, didn’t take heed the warnings because I thought I could fight it. Or maybe it was because I was more comfortable with the one being loved less. Whatever the reason, the end result is always the same. I’m old enough to know better by now but too young to change it. TC mark

You should follow Thought Catalog on Twitter here.



Image via CarbonNYC

Cataloged in

Text Size:

A | A | A

  • http://www.facebook.com/profile.php?id=707272007 Alex Thayer

    why so serious

  • Sam Monserrate

    Damn that gave a fresh sting

  • http://profiles.google.com/thisisaliecalledlife Byron Burns

    I thought it. You wrote it. As always. 

  • http://twitter.com/Zeyadsalem Zeyad Salem

    Loved the last two paragraphs :)

  • Tori Houston

    Perfection >> “It’s amazing how many Sundays you can endure with a limp rag doll. The more you can get rejected, the more you want to prove yourself.” 

  • Anonymous

    “You know the dynamics of a relationship from the beginning.”

    this. is. truth.

  • Mashka

    “The worst is an unattended heart.”— truth. 

  • Mashka

    I always go after a challenge. It’s kinda pathetic. Why is it that I try so hard with my heart and feelings and mind for someone who isn’t making the effort, and yet I run away from the ones that are being perfect and making the effort and treating me the way I should be? fucked. up. 

  • Sam Monserrate

    I just discovered Thought Catalog yesterday. My favorite article so far was “upon Realizing you Don’t love your Ex” and after that, I bookmarked this damn page. 

  • Anonymous

    I feel this.

  • http://twitter.com/alyssagoesbang alyssa n. ammirato

    oh so perfectly captured

  • S.

    You’re inside my head, it’s creepy, but so unbelievably contorting knowing I’m not alone in this

  • jessica

    we might be brain twins.

  • Mashka

    Oh neat how timely here’s a prime example: Guy that I poured my heart out to with feelings for him, after him telling me he has feelings for me and we hook up, etc… he’s now dating someone else thus knows I clearly still have feelings and yet has the audacity to say “sorry it’s date night” to me in response to me asking if he’s gonna come by tonight to hang out. FUCK. YOU. 

  • douchegirl

    I liked it. I feel like I could have written this myself. 

  • Guest

    Yeah.
    You aren’t even able to voice these feelings in a relationship -  you are completely alone in knowing it and it hurts so, so, so bad.

  • http://twitter.com/kaimcn Kai

    I love love love the pain and torture and exhilaration of love, but the sting of a broken (or smashed) heart is starting to lose its appeal.

  • Sophia

    and the question i’m left with is, what can we do to avoid this? what can we do to make sure he won’t wake up tomorrow morning and feel differently? is there anything? what keeps relationships together? is it just a crapshoot?

    i hate this i hate this i hate this lack of control.

  • Sophia

    THIS.
    What can you say? “Hey, so I’ve noticed lately you’ve been falling out of love with me. Can we do something about that?”

    It’s so sad.

  • http://twitter.com/omglolhahaha Alison Hess

    Being the one who loves less is no picnic either.  At least in the underloved scenario you have the righteousness of feeling.

  • Heather Inc

    This is why you’re my favorite.

  • B Diaz

    THIS ARTICLE SPEAKS TO ME ON SO MANY LEVELS. PREACH! PREAAAACH!

  • http://twitter.com/mung_beans Mung Beans

    Yeah, it’s hard to get your heart broken but it’s really hard to do the breaking.

  • http://www.facebook.com/profile.php?id=2311203 Kevin Pritchard

    Ryan needs to smoke more pot, or something. 

  • ASURAD123

    You are amazing.

  • http://twitter.com/Buffalogal Nicole Shoe

    thank you for this. going through some shit and nice to know im not alone.

  • Anonymous

    you should read “Don’t date a girl who reads”. It’s the article that introduced me to the site. Not my favorite anymore since it’s slightly immature but still brilliant all the same

  • Anonymous

    “ I’m old enough to know better by now but too young to change it.” Perfect line. Is it that terrible to love somebody more than they love you. I wonder how they feel about loving less…

  • Anonymous

    haha the image for this article is a broken heart with the words email me. Perfect.

  • Greg Zaragoza

    Wow.  If the guy who broke my heart reads Thought Catalog as often as he said he does…

  • Guest

    then don’t date

  • Guest

    just make it easy on everyone and end it

  • Guest

    because you hate yourself, clearly. get some self esteem and then find someone good.

  • Goldmund

    Yeah, this seems harsh but is absolutely true. As corny as it sounds, but you have to love yourself before you can love anyone else…

  • Anonymous

    Woosh, this felt so good to read. Right? The first time they lie there? You want to change everything at once, then you pull away and they don’t chase.

  • http://kelianaya.com Keli Anaya

    I know what it’s like. Sorry, Ryan. 

  • Jessica Ann

    “I started to sense some resistance on your end though. Your body just
    hung there like a limp rag doll and that’s when I realized that you were
    rejecting me. I was being rejected on a day where everything was
    supposed to feel close and that’s when I understood that this
    relationship was living on borrowed time. That’s when I knew you were
    not going to break my heart but that you were actually breaking my
    heart.”

    This. At the end of July I broke up with my boyfriend of 5 years. Or, we broke up. I knew his head and heart were no longer in it, though my entire soul still was. Is. I remember this moment for us. I remember the moment when I knew he was not simply going to end up breaking my heart, but was starting to actively break it, little by little. That was nearly 5 months before we ended. Those 5 months were torture. I never knew exactly where his head was. Some days he was there, many he was not. I wanted to believe I could fix everything if I was “the perfect girlfriend.” I turned a blind eye to so many things, forgave things I should not have forgiven, and sacrificed a lot of myself in hopes that he’d look at me one day and think, “Hm, she’s pretty awesome and I’m happy where I’m at.”

    It never happened. And now it’s been almost 3 months. This person who I knew inside and out, who I spent 5 years of my life with, who in every sense of the word became my family…this person is now a stranger. And it kills me.

  • Ashki

    Sometimes you are so spot on. Damn.

  • Anonymous

    oh thank you for your useful input you big IDIOT how about we just never go out with people or never have sex or never enjoy life F U U SUK

  • LazyReader

    God damn that’s good.

  • xosause

    You’ve written practically everything that just happened to me in the past 2 weeks. I just have gone through it enough times to have it hurt me more than it should’ve been…

  • Anonymous

    “The worst is an unattended heart. It’s not full, it’s not empty; it’s just there. That kind of make you feel like you’re dead inside and everything is just stagnant. The worst.”
    Wish I wrote this.

  • Laurie

    You ignored the signs because you thought your love could make them love you someday. You thought that you could change them. 

  • Sam Monserrate

    Ohh yes I loved that article too! Saw that on tumblr, didn’t really know it was originally from this site. awesome. 

  • Sophia

    well. i read this article in the middle of a failing relationship, and it resonated with me, and i still thought i could fight it. and it ended. just like this. ryan mcconnell, i don’t know why i don’t trust you enough yet to just make my decisions for me. i would be a lot better off.

  • Guest

    yep, once again ryan knows my life.

  • Heartbreak Champion

    Going through this right now. Keep going to bed at night wishing I’ll wake up one day and she’ll say, “I’ve been crazy all along! I’m head over heels!” But I know she won’t. I’m ignoring the signs I know I shouldn’t be. I’m forgiving the things that don’t deserve forgiveness. It’s silly, it’s dumb, it’s hard on the both of us. But neither of us will end it, not yet anyway. There’s something so comforting in the poison.

  • lastunicornalive

    This struck me like a lightning bolt. We’re not dumb, we just refuse to get our brains on top of our heads. And feel proud though, coz people like us have a great threshold of pain. The sun will shine again, hahaha #dumbanddumber

Recently Cataloged

  • Confessions Of An International Traveler

    The first time I got drunk and threw up was the first time I was abroad: I was in Prague, and I was 17. I lied and told the people I was with that I had been drunk before, but I hadn’t and I overdid it. I very clearly remember puking, and thinking to myself, “Well, this is stupid.”

    Nicole Trilivas is the author of the novel, PRETTY GIRLS MAKE GRAVES.
  • 26 Lesser-Known Reasons To Call Your Girlfriend

    It’s also time that you two “had the talk.” But in this case, “the talk” is about how you need more dish soap, and you’re really sorry that you forgot to put it on the list, but you didn’t think she was going to go to the store straight from work.
    Laura lives and writes in NYC.
  • 8 Ways Female Party Animals Behave Like Actual Animals

    Hell hath no fury like a hungry drunk girl. A drunk girl who wants (NEEDS) food is more dangerous then an angry dinosaur who wants her stolen egg back.
    Donielle Muransky lives and writes in New York City. For now.
  • My Letter To Cosmopolitan Magazine

    The tip I found most upsetting was “Try placing a donut on your man’s shaft. Then go down on him while slowly devouring the tasty treat.” You see, Cosmo, I have Celiac’s Disease, which means I can’t eat wheat flour, the #1 ingredient in donuts. It’s tragic to think of all the ways this negatively impacts my sex life.

    Alison Griffin Vingiano is a Brooklyn based writer & comedian.