Reasons Why You Shouldn’t Be Friends With Your Ex

Sep. 8, 2011
Ryan O’Connell is a 25 year-old writer based in the East Village, New York.

You shared everything together. They saw you cry for no reason at all at two o’clock in the morning. They know about the issues you have with your parents, they picked out the olives in your salad because they knew you hated them. They may have sucked on your balls, for God’s sake. They went down on your vagina! So why settle for a watered down version of what you used to have? Every time you see them you’re just going to think, “I sucked on your balls and now we’re drinking iced tea and talking about the weather.” No thanks.

It’ll be tortuous, especially if you still want to sleep with them. You’re no longer allowed to do so. You own no more stocks on their body. You’ve been bought out. As you sit there actively trying to be friends, you’re going to grow resentful about the fact that you can longer kiss them. Just a little while ago, you could do whatever you wanted to their body and their face, and now it’s the one thing you’re not allowed to touch. You might just scream at them, “Why can’t I just touch your penis/vagina anymore?! It used to be mine to touch. Give it back!” I wouldn’t actually recommend saying that though because you might be called crazy.

It will hurt too much. Listen, there’s no shame in not being an evolved grown up. No one said that we had to be friends with our exes. We can give into our insane feelings and say, “Screw you! You hurt me badly and I have no interest in shooting the breeze with you. We only do it so we can pat ourselves on the back afterwards and I don’t want to give you that satisfaction.”

If they were the one who broke your heart, hanging out with them is going to make you feel so undesirable. You’ll try to look really cute when you go on your friendship date, in hopes that it will make them want you again. They’ll say, “Oh my god. That tank top you’re wearing has reminded me why I fell in love with you. Let’s get back together!” No, it’s not going to happen. You could go to these things looking like absolute garbage or royalty and it wouldn’t make a lick of difference. They’ve already fallen out of love with you and that won’t change if you’re having a good hair day.

Some exes we can be friends with. Some we can get lunch with and not think about the fact that we once licked their genitalia. But some exes are a “NEVER” in the friendship category. These are the people we hurt the most or who hurt us the most. And it’s okay to say “See you later!” It doesn’t make us immature, it makes us smart. If being an adult means subjecting ourselves to pure torture with someone who used to love us, then call me Peter Goddamn Pan. TC mark

You should follow Thought Catalog on Twitter here.

image – (c)iStockphoto.com, Milos Jokic

Cataloged in

Text Size:

A | A | A

  • http://summerslowrunner.wordpress.com/ Summer

    This is 100% truth.

    I do constantly think about having had sex with that person, seeing them naked, being intimate together. It’s such feigned bullshit to “meet for a drink and catch up” when you know damn good and well you still want to be S’ing that D.

    Ugh. Exes.

  • Anonymous

    Again, not impossible to remain friends with the exes, unless you’re not over them and still want to jump their balls. THEN WHY PRETEND TO BE THEIR FRIEND?! Get over it and move on. Move on, be fair to yourself, then maybeee salvage a friendship. 

  • Anonymous

    Again, not impossible to remain friends with the exes, unless you’re not over them and still want to jump their balls. THEN WHY PRETEND TO BE THEIR FRIEND?! Get over it and move on. Move on, be fair to yourself, then maybeee salvage a friendship. 

  • Anonymous

    Again, not impossible to remain friends with the exes, unless you’re not over them and still want to jump their balls. THEN WHY PRETEND TO BE THEIR FRIEND?! Get over it and move on. Move on, be fair to yourself, then maybeee salvage a friendship. 

  • saritapatrice

    “If being an adult means subjecting ourselves to pure torture with someone who used to love us, then call me Peter Goddamn Pan.” Love it.

  • http://www.wilfordlauren.tumblr.com Lauren Wilford

    Unless, of course, you’re “being friends for a while” to “see if we can develop better communication habits.”

    Wait, people don’t do that? Oh. 

  • Toodle68

    It all depends on why you broke up.  My relationship ended last week and I just could not bring myself to remain friends. It is too painful.  Sometimes, keeping in contact might help reconcile, sometimes no contact can help bring them back.  There is no one answer to the best approach.

  • Anonymous

    good luck to you, friend :[

  • chris

    “Oh my god. That tank top you’re wearing has reminded me why I fell in love with you. Let’s get back together!”

    I always try this.

  • chris

    “Oh my god. That tank top you’re wearing has reminded me why I fell in love with you. Let’s get back together!”

    I always try this.

  • http://profiles.google.com/steven.timberman Steven Timberman

    The Peter Pan line is fairly fucking awesome.

    And “meet for a drink” really just means ‘Let’s both try and secretly judge to see who of us is ‘winning’. See also, old friends and colleagues. 

    but since you’ve… er, S’ed their D or L’ed their V everything is much more heightened. And competitive. Good fucking christ is it ever.

  • http://profiles.google.com/steven.timberman Steven Timberman

    The Peter Pan line is fairly fucking awesome.

    And “meet for a drink” really just means ‘Let’s both try and secretly judge to see who of us is ‘winning’. See also, old friends and colleagues. 

    but since you’ve… er, S’ed their D or L’ed their V everything is much more heightened. And competitive. Good fucking christ is it ever.

  • coffeeandinternets

    So true. But Ryan — you live in New York.  It’s the Never Never Land of actual places — no one ever has to grow up. And the sewer alligators. Also.

    Anyway — it’s easier to give friends this advice, oftentimes, than listen to it yourself.

    I wish “GIRL ARE YOU SERIOUS” resonated so strongly in my head as it does through my mouth.

  • Ryan_lover

    how do you know everything?

  • a.

    If they were the one who broke your heart, hanging out with them is
    going to make you feel so undesirable. You’ll try to look really cute
    when you go on your friendship date, in hopes that it will make them
    want you again. They’ll say, “Oh my god. That tank top you’re wearing
    has reminded me why I fell in love with you. Let’s get back together!”

    You mean that doesn’t work?

  • Punky Triumph

    Ha!  This is amazing. Just like the rest of your essays. Thanks. I agree. Once the tie is severed I think having an emotional/physical “restraining order” is the best way to go. I’ve had ex’s midst break-ups say the “let’s be friends” BS and my retort is, “that’s ok I already have enough friends.” Apples are apples and oranges are oranges. You can’t turn an apple into an orange…nope.

  • Anonymous Guest

    Ryan. All you ever write about are a) relationships and b) homosexuality. Why is this? Have you nothing else to base your life upon and translate into well-constructed sentences? Have you no hobbies but getting laid, being gay, and falling in love? Your one-dimensional nature pisses me off to no end.

    Go read a book.

  • Amy

    I know of some people I should send this to.

  • kim

    you make some good points, but i don’t think it’s a valid enough reason to cut someone out of your life. i try to stay friends with every guy i’ve been involved with because they all made me happy at one point in my life. even if you can’t forget what you had, as long as you can get along as friends and there are no hard feelings, then make the most of what you CAN have. life is too short for that kind of pettiness. 

  • http://www.facebook.com/people/Jordan-Fields/100000625951408 Jordan Fields

    Also tortuous is not the same as torturous.  Torturous is reading one of your piece

  • Leah

    I’m taking a leap of faith and deciding that there’s more to Ryan than relationships and homosexuality. Just throwing that out there.
    Assuming that might be true, what is so bad about writing about those things, especially of you do it well?
    Ryan, I find your writing relatable, accessible and your literary voice really speaks to me. Thank you.

  • Robert.

    if you are hot enough, it works.

  • AC

    THANK YOU!  Why is it so hard for some people to understand such a simple concept?!

  • Guest

    another good reason is that being friends with them might alienate your present gf/bf. JUST SAYIN

  • aa

    BUT what if the exes are sleeping together :/

  • http://www.facebook.com/profile.php?id=10036647 Aimee Vondrak

    I think Ryan is good at writing articulately about these things and not just random stream of thought nonsense like some of the other regular writers on this site. So maybe he’s like two dimensional. But whatever, he’s a good writer so byeee~

  • http://www.facebook.com/profile.php?id=10036647 Aimee Vondrak

    I’m going to go out on a limb and say it is probably too soon for you to know whether you can be friends EVER. Maybe you can later and maybe it will be good for you and you’ll be happy you did :)

  • http://twitter.com/bybeautydamned Maria Carreon

    I love my ex because he has already seen the worst person I can possibly be and he still likes me.  We SO do not have sex or even think about it.  But I can still nag him and bitch at him until the sun no longer shines and he just says, “okay, sorry, see you later” and LEAVES!  I love it.  And he still comes over and takes care of me when my back is out and helps me take out the trash and recycling (which he never wanted to do when we were together) and clips the cat’s claws because I’m too afraid to do it. I highly recommend being friends with your ex if it’s someone you value a friendship with. It can be the best kind of relationship you’ll ever have if you just put aside the drama and realize that there’s nothing like someone who you’ve already destroyed your relationship with until there’s not much left to lose.

  • Aisla Uuttu

    That’s the kind of attitude I like. I never dated douchebags anyway, why should I, when I can date a sweet and caring person instead? Someone who I’ll never lose from my life, even if and when the romantic relationship is gone. If the thing in dating someone consists mainly of touching their privates, it’s no wonder it can prove hard to be friends with them when they become exes. Sweet life, you had NOTHING else in common? You weren’t best friends with your partner at the same time you were lovers? What was the point of the whole relationship then? Stupid people…

  • Aisla Uuttu

    Yeah, it just might. If s/he is a JERK, that is. And by that I mean someone who hasn’t realized that this is NOT O.C. or Glee, this is real life, and everyone (at least the ACTUALLY socially smart people, who are good to hang out with) are not trying to stab you in the back. Be honest and open and eventually you’ll get honesty and openness in return.

  • Aisla Uuttu

    Just adding, since I realized some people can take my reply to this post quite wrong. I’m not saying you can be friends with everyone. Especially if your ex is emotionally fucked up and a social vampire who drains everyone around them of their joy and strength. THOSE you should leave alone for everyone’s good, and also learn to leave alone in the future too when you’re searching for a partner.

  • Aisla Uuttu

    Point, and a good one at that. But Ryan, try to keep in mind that not everywhere is like New York. Probably this advice of yours works there, but trust me – in most places and situations, it won’t. This is a well-written article, but a bit (okay, a lot) narrow-minded/one-eyed, don’t you think?

  • Aisla Uuttu

    Point, and a good one at that. But Ryan, try to keep in mind that not everywhere is like New York. Probably this advice of yours works there, but trust me – in most places and situations, it won’t. This is a well-written article, but a bit (okay, a lot) narrow-minded/one-eyed, don’t you think?

  • Aisla Uuttu

    Then you ought to learn to let go of them. Of course you can’t be friends with someone you are fixated over sexually. But why be stupid like that? That is the one part of this I can not comprehend at all.

  • http://www.facebook.com/nattusmith Natt Smith

    I love licking balls. 

  • Guest

    Agreed. TC seems to have two kinds of articles: intriguing, well-written ones that inspire and educate and evoke a little more love for the human race… and Ryan O’Connell’s vapid, self-absorbed judgmental bullshit. I mean it in the most insulting way when I say that I can tell which articles are his on TC’s homepage simply based on reading the titles.

    What’s sad is the “bad teenage poetry” he egotistically decided to post and then analyze (http://thoughtcatalog.com/2011/translating-my-bad-teenage-poetry/) is infinitely more eloquent and genuine than any of the utter trash that he writes now with the pathetic belief that he is witty and original and “like, so over it!”

  • http://twitter.com/rainbowcouch Rainbow Couch

    Ryan, wise words, as usual. I’m off to post it on my practice FB page and tweet it!
    Ronete, the shrink who loves what you write.

  • Mishmatheus

    What if you are in love with your best friend? and he’s gay? what happenz then? ugh. So UNFAIR!

  • Ryan O’Connell

    MAMA MISH.

  • An admirer

    get over yourself its just a fucking typo; obviously Ryan and all of us know the difference between tortuous and torturous

  • guest

    Or if you try to remain friends you try and go out for a coffee or tea to see if you can remain friends instead of thinking “why can’t I touch you anymore” you just end up sleeping together…over and over. And this leads to a completely new set of confusing feelings. 

  • Jordan

    My ex is my best friend -.-

  • Guest

    Maybe it’s just me, but I find that if someone was capable of hurting you once, they will most likely do it again, whether it’s intentional or not. So no, I’m not friends with any ex that broke my heart…I’ve tried it, because it seemed like one should be friends with the first person they ever loved. But those things never end up working, do they?

  • http://pulse.yahoo.com/_CXCS7TXFL5TS2LGXRPMARVGOHY Viktor

    In the wise words of the Mancunian poet, Liam Fray: “Please don’t pretend that we’ll stay friends, ’cause that just, will never happen”

  • guest

    AMEN TO THAT

  • kas

    I feel rather lucky that I can still be friends to most of my exs. Heck, one of them have even become my best friend.

    Perhaps it is because it had been so long ago since we broke up. 

  • jenn

    been there. it sucks.

  • jenn

    this made me cry. because as much as i want my ex in my life, i’m realizing now, i just cant.

  • 67_Buick

    If you have strong enough feelings for the other person the idea of being friends with an ex is simply ridiculous. You’re only kidding yourself, it will still make you feel like poo when you hang out. I believe people who aren’t honest with themselves are ok with “ex’s as friends.” Believe me I’ve been there. It’s a way for them to keep on controlling you. Make a stand, let your feelings known and do not contact them for as long as possible to show them how you truly feel. Don’t show any signs of weakness and if you need to see them in person just play it indifferent and cool not friendly. I am a guy and going through th same s— now

Recently Cataloged