20 Under 40: A Comprehensive (Subjective) Guide

Nov. 29, 2010
Daniel Roberts is currently a magazine reporter. He went to college at Middlebury and grad school at Columbia. ...

Salvatore Scibona, “The Kid,” June 14/21:

Salvatore Scibona
Carlos Ferguson

With this story about a young father (Elroy) who abandons his son (Janis) at an airport, I think Scibona’s biggest achievement was inhabiting the minds of both characters (and shifting between the two every few pages). The story is told in third-person, but only from the mind of the son or the father. Take this, when Janis is sitting with airport officers that have brought him to a room and treated him with a mixture of aggravation and good intentions: “Why did it feel goodto cry? For ages, Janis had wondered what was the matter with him that when he cried, which was feeling bad, it felt good somehow.”

Elroy makes it onto another flight and finds his father, apparently with very little guilt about leaving the boy, and Janis is still with authorities when we leave him. By the end, we’re a few years in the future and Elroy gets a letter from his former wife asking about her son. We can only imagine that he’s going to have a hard time answering that letter.

But you have to wonder where the hell the kid ended up, if anyone ever tracks down Elroy to make him responsible for what he left behind, etc. In that regard, this may have been a piece of a novel. And in the Q&A with the New Yorker, Scibona says that the idea came from when he “saw a young boy at a ticket counter, sobbing. He seemed unexceptional until I realized that the women trying to comfort him were not his guardians, did not know him, and could not figure out what language he was speaking… I have no idea what became of him.” Then, asked what he’s now working on, he answers “A novel.” Could be obvious.

I hope this wasn’t an excerpt. I think it works better as a short story. And because the boy is literally left standing in the airport, I’m left thinking of this story more than many of the others.


Cataloged in

Text Size:

A | A | A

  • Ganjaman1010

    Would have loved to see Shteyngart write something short, too

  • Max's Henchman

    One person doing 20 reviews? What a beast! This feat merits a review in itself.

  • anon

    i think what one should really be concerned about is whether there is any real value in grouping together authors under 40 years old, as if there were some sort of writing equivalent to the fields medal…

  • Parly

    This is epic.

  • HB

    jesus! major undertaking. the best story was Sciboner.

blog comments powered by Disqus

Recently Cataloged

  • moto

    Life Is A Highway, But You Shouldn’t Ride It, Part II

    Try something today. Count how many times someone brings up some sort of mental illness in normal conversation. Add that number up and tell me it doesn’t strike you as kind of weird how many normal people walk around with the belief that there is something wrong with them.

    Ted Winkworth is a former touring musician turned higher education professional. His current project, ...
  • Cologne

    Cologne

    She assumed it was jewelry. Every year he gets her a charm for her gold chain or a pair of dangly earrings.

    Kelcey is a Long Island based 20-something who is obsessed with Bloody Mary's and conforming the world to eating more ...
  • fall

    Everything Is Falling

    Fall if you will, but rise you must.

    Oliver has a MFA in fiction from a very expensive college, but has never published any fiction. He has written for ...
  • Sometimes You Gotta Live Más

    Sometimes You Gotta Live Más

    You may lose what would have been the joy of the experience had you not been so focused on some fabricated idea or unrealistic expectation you had of how it was going to turn out.

    Sarah has trekked through the nordic forests of Sweden, survived multiple floods at Bonnaroo and studied abroad in ...